Client anonymity in psychotherapy. The architecture of trust

Дана
Дана Янсон
7 апреля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Client anonymity in psychotherapy. The architecture of trust

Confidentiality in psychotherapy is traditionally discussed within the framework of basic ethics. We are accustomed to relying on ethical codes of professional associations, perceiving non-disclosure of data as a given rule of good manners and respect for the client. However, as our profession becomes digitalized and attempts are made to regulate it legislatively, it becomes obvious that confidentiality and the right to anonymity are not just points in informed consent. They are the load-bearing structure, the very architecture of providing psychological help.

In this article, I propose to analyze the issue of anonymity and data protection from clinical, legal, and technological points of view, and to look at how modern digital platforms and legislative initiatives affect the safety of the therapeutic setting.

The clinical value of anonymity. The right to a "clean slate"

At the heart of any psychotherapeutic approach lies the concept of a safe space. For the client to place their feelings in this space, to be able to touch upon repressed, shameful, or frightening parts of their psyche, they need this reliable "container." The guarantee that their words, fantasies, and symptoms will never be linked to their social identity provides the necessary therapeutic effect.

Often, we face situations where the fear of de-anonymization blocks access to the central issues. Let me give an example from a recent supervision (all data completely anonymized).

The client, let's call him Nikolay, sought help for social anxiety and procrastination. The first sessions were difficult, resistance was strong. In the fifth session, after repeated clarifications about how records were stored and if the therapist knew his real surname, the client admitted to severe obsessive-compulsive symptoms related to intrusive thoughts (frightening thoughts of harming loved ones).

The fear of being considered "crazy" or potentially dangerous, and that this information could leak somewhere, made him discuss a superficial request for months. As soon as the anonymity framework was confirmed and strengthened, the real work began.

Anonymity allows the client not to expend psychic energy on impression management. When a person knows that they are communicating with a therapist under a pseudonym, their psyche relaxes its defenses faster. The right not to reveal one's passport name, place of work, or social status is the right to come to therapy only with one's pain, without social masks.

Scientific basis: research on self-disclosure

The link between privacy guarantees and treatment effectiveness has been confirmed by numerous studies. The American Psychological Association (APA) has repeatedly published data showing that the fear of stigma and information leakage is the main barrier to seeking help for depression, PTSD, and addictions.

In foreign literature (for example, in Sweeney et al.'s research on privacy in digital healthcare), it is emphasized that even the slightest doubt a patient has about the reliability of data storage reduces the level of self-disclosure by 40-50%. Clients begin to censor their stories.

In Russian practice, we observe a similar picture. Studies dedicated to the stigmatization of psychiatric and psychological care (including works by the school of A.B. Kholmogorova and N.G. Garanyan) show that the fear of social consequences – being registered, problems with employment, condemnation from loved ones – forces people to endure until severe clinical conditions develop. The guarantee of anonymity in this context acts not just as a convenience, but as a factor that saves the quality, and sometimes even the life, of a person.

Legal vacuum and threats of legislative initiatives

For a long time, psychological counseling in Russia was in a legal grey area. Unlike psychiatrists and medical psychotherapists, whose activities are strictly protected by the concept of "medical confidentiality" (Article 13 of Federal Law-323 "On the Fundamentals of Healthcare in the Russian Federation"), non-medical psychologists relied solely on internal ethical codes.

However, an ethical code has no legal force when faced with requests from state structures. Currently, attempts at legislative regulation of the industry are actively discussed within the professional community. In particular, the draft law "On the Fundamentals of Psychological Activity in the Russian Federation," submitted to the State Duma by a group of deputies led by N.A. Ostanina, raises serious questions regarding the interpretation of confidentiality.

The draft law proposes introducing the concept of "psychological confidentiality." In itself, this is a necessary and correct step. The profession urgently needs a legal status of confidentiality, similar, for example, to attorney-client privilege. However, the devil is in the details – in the current versions of the draft laws, the grounds for disclosing this confidentiality are interpreted excessively broadly.

Of particular concern is the possibility of providing information constituting psychological confidentiality upon requests from investigative bodies, inquiry bodies, courts, and notaries (in connection with the opening of an inheritance and the need to assess the state of the testator). While the disclosure of information by court order in the framework of serious crimes makes logical sense for public protection, the inclusion of notaries or investigators at the inquiry stage (without a court decision) completely destroys trust in our psychotherapeutic work.

Let's imagine a situation where a client is going through a difficult divorce with property division or is dividing an inheritance. If they know that their words spoken in the psychologist's office (about their emotional instability, breakdowns, doubts about their adequacy) can be officially requested by a notary or the opposing party's lawyer for discrediting purposes, they simply won't seek therapy. Or they will meticulously filter every word. The therapeutic office will turn into a branch of a courtroom, where the client is forced to give testimony beneficial to their social position.

The legislative codification of psychological confidentiality should primarily protect the client, making the psychologist's office an absolutely safe zone from which information can only be released in exceptional cases (direct threat to life).

The Architecture of Digital Anonymity: Why a Phone Number is a Passport

Today, a significant part of psychological assistance is provided online. Here, we encounter a deep contradiction between the clinical requirements for the setting and the marketing logic of IT products.

The vast majority of psychologist selection services (aggregators) build client authorization through a mobile phone number. For the IT sector, this is a standard path (onboarding). But let's look at this through the eyes of a specialist who understands the realities of the Russian digital space.

In our country, a mobile phone number has long ceased to be just a set of digits for calling. It is tied to passport data (according to the communications law), to the State Services portal, to banking applications, and social networks. A phone number is an absolute and unambiguous identifier of a person, equivalent to a passport.

When an aggregator requires client verification by phone number, it effectively deprives them of the right to genuine anonymity. Any database leak (and in recent years, we've seen that even the largest corporations and banks are not immune to this) means that the fact of a person seeking psychological help, and sometimes the profile of their problems (if initial diagnostic tests are saved in the database), will become public knowledge.

Why do aggregators do this? The answer lies in the business model. A phone number is needed for sales funnel operations: for aggressive marketing, sending SMS with promotions, calls reminding about a session “left in the cart.” But psychotherapy is not pizza delivery. It’s a delicate, intimate process that does not tolerate marketing pressure. When a client receives a push notification “20% off a session, come back to work through anxiety,” it’s not just a boundary violation, it’s a profanation of the very meaning of psychological help.

The architecture of a secure platform must be built on the principle of data minimization. To provide quality online psychological services, two elements are sufficient: an encrypted email (for restoring access to the personal account) and a pseudonym. The client has every right to use any name and communicate through an email created specifically for these purposes. The platform’s task is to ensure uninterrupted video communication and a secure payment channel, not to collect a patient’s digital profile for targeting.

Corporate psychotherapy (B2B): a test for absolute security

The problem of de-anonymization is even more acute in the corporate psychotherapy segment (EAP programs — Employee Assistance Programs). More and more companies offer employees paid sessions with a psychologist as part of their social package. This is a wonderful initiative that often founders on employee mistrust.

Let me give another example from supervision practice.

A client, a middle manager, sought help from a private therapist with signs of burnout and a severe depressive episode provoked by a toxic work environment (mobbing from management). When asked by the therapist why she didn't use the free corporate psychological support program, she replied: “Authorization in this program goes through the corporate portal. I don't believe that the HR department doesn't receive lists of those who seek help. If they find out that I'm struggling and complaining about management, I'll be fired at the first staff optimization.”

This is a classic example of how a flawed confidentiality architecture kills a good idea. If a corporate support program is structured so that the employer can match the allocated budget with a specific employee (for example, by issuing personalized promo codes or requiring authorization via work email), employees will only bring “safe” requests to the corporate psychologist: time management, goal setting, mild procrastination. True problems — depression, addictions, workplace conflicts, suicidal thoughts — will remain in the shadows.

In the corporate segment, anonymity must be embedded at the code level. The employer should receive exclusively anonymized statistics: number of hours spent, general company trends (e.g., “30% of requests are related to burnout”), satisfaction indices. Financial billing must be completely decoupled from clinical data. An employee must be able to access the platform, use a common corporate pool of hours, but in the visible part remain for the platform and their employer simply “client #4815.” Only in this case does corporate therapy begin to work as a tool for real help, and not as a tool for hidden control by HR.

In conclusion

Confidentiality and anonymity in our profession are not additional options or competitive advantages. They are the basic sanitary norms of the psychological process.

In a climate where the state seeks to increase control over information, and businesses — to collect as much data as possible to boost sales, the responsibility for maintaining the boundaries of the therapeutic setting falls on the professional community. We must advocate for our clients' right to 'psychological confidentiality' at the legislative level, critically evaluate the tools we use for online work, and demand that digital platforms adhere to clinical logic, not just marketing KPIs. Only by building a robust architecture of trust can we guarantee clients the level of safety without which genuine psychotherapy is simply impossible.


Dana Yanson psychoanalyst, Candidate of Psychological Sciences, 
founder of the online platform for professional psychotherapy proEgo


From the Editors: On the Choice of Illustration

The choice of visual accompaniment for this material was not accidental. The editorial team deliberately chose the work of a contemporary artist because the discussed problem — digital anonymity and boundary protection in an era of a 'transparent' society — is a challenge of our time, requiring a relevant visual language. The painting by Amy Shackleton «Melting Point (England + Canada)» serves as a precise metaphor for the 'elusive' setting. Her unique technique, imitating drips and the melting effect of monumental architectural forms, vividly illustrates the central idea of the article: even the most stable, seemingly immutable foundations of the therapeutic space can 'melt away' under the pressure of technological deanonymization and marketing algorithms, if their internal architecture is not built with modern risks in mind.


List of References and Sources

  1. Federal Law No. 323-FZ of 21.11.2011 (as amended on 25.12.2023) "On the Fundamentals of Protecting the Health of Citizens in the Russian Federation". Article 13. Observance of Medical Confidentiality.

  2. Draft Federal Law No. 202611-8 "On the Fundamentals of Psychological Activity in the Russian Federation" (introduced by Deputy N.A. Ostanina et al.). — Text : electronic // System for Ensuring Legislative Activity : [website]. — URL: https://sozd.duma.gov.ru/bill/202611-8 (accessed: 07.04.2026).

  3. Ethical Code of a Psychologist. Adopted by the V Congress of the Russian Psychological Society on February 14, 2012. — Text : electronic // Russian Psychological Society : [website]. — URL: http://рпо.рф/rpo/documentation/ethics.php (accessed: 07.04.2026).

  4. American Psychological Association (APA). Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct. Section 4: Privacy and Confidentiality. — Text : electronic // APA : [website]. — URL: https://www.apa.org/ethics/code (accessed: 07.04.2026).

  5. Garanyan, N. G. Stigmatization of Persons with Mental Disorders: Modern Approaches to the Problem / N. G. Garanyan, A. B. Kholmogorova. // Psychological Science and Education. — 2011. — Vol. 16. — No. 3. — Pp. 5–16.

  6. Kholmogorova, A. B. Culture, psychological distress and destigmatization / A. B. Kholmogorova. // Counseling Psychology and Psychotherapy. — 2014. — Vol. 22. — No. 1. — P. 8–24.

  7. Sweeney, C. Privacy-Preserving Bio-Pharmaceutical Data Access / C. Sweeney, P. Karr, J. Shaver. // Journal of Biomedical Informatics. — 2013. — Vol. 46, Special Issue. — P. S15-S22. — Text : electronic. — URL: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbi.2013.06.009 (accessed: 07.04.2026).

  8. Vance, J. Stigma, Confidentiality, and the Internet: Ethical Considerations in Utilizing Digital Health Tools in HIV Care / J. Vance, J. A. Powsner. // Mental Health and Addiction Research. — 2018. — Vol. 3(1). — P. 1-6.

  9. Winnicott, D. W. The Holding Environment / D. W. Winnicott. // The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment: Studies in the Theory of Emotional Development. — London : Hogarth Press, 1965. — P. 239–256.

Views: 564

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!