Anorexia: A Case Study of an Eating Disorder

Психология
Денис
Денис Куличков
9 февраля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Anorexia: A Case Study of an Eating Disorder

«As soon as Ivan-tsarevich hears a knock and thunder, he must tell the guests: 'My little frog in a box is coming.' The tsarevich did everything exactly as the frog had told him. When the noise subsided and the royal gates opened, it was not a frog, but a tsarevna of extraordinary beauty who appeared. Ivan-tsarevich, not believing his happiness, immediately ran home and burned the frog's skin in the oven.»

In the January issue of «E-J» I described the meta-model of the human psychic apparatus in the article «The 'Child' and the 'Adult': Two Poles of the Psychic World» — the very material about the «child part,» which is actually psychotic. And today I want to show you how an anorexic patient is seen through this prism.

As you understand, I cannot publish the details of the case, so the text will only contain some key points. Everything I will write cannot be perceived from the perspective of classical logic, but this is the material from working with the client that allows understanding their psychotic core. The place where the pathology resides.

Clinical Picture: Aggression as a «Cloud of Dust»

In general, what is contained in the case corresponds to the typical behavior of an anorexic patient. So, before us is a girl with anorexia and bulimia.

In psychoanalysis, these diseases are related to an attack on the body — both one's own and the Mother's body. This disease is also directly related to aggression. This does not mean that people with such a diagnosis behave aggressively, no. The matter is different: aggression exists in their psychic apparatus like a cloud of dust permeating the atmosphere.

What happens in sessions:

  • She schedules meetings and cancels them.
  • She finds it difficult to speak; her speech conveys constant diffuse suffering (as if there is no single place where peace exists).
  • The girl violates all possible agreements with the analyst, devalues his work, and attacks the rules.
  • The narrative material of the sessions is scarce, offering almost no opportunity for interpretations.

The patient is under the care of a psychiatrist, but sabotages her medication intake in a specific way: she places the pill in her mouth and immediately takes it out, putting it back in the pillbox. As we understand, something similar happens with food during bulimic episodes (a cycle of ingestion and expulsion).

Countertransference: What happens to the analyst?

The analyst feels a special way about this young woman. He wants to become «special» to her. For some reason, he distorts her name in session notes, removing the letter «Я» from it. In his fantasies during the session, the image of a breast with an inverted nipple regularly appears. The analyst's feelings are complex, almost unbearable. Between sessions, he thinks about this client and even responds to her messages in messengers and emails, violating the boundaries of the setting.

Important Caveat: Anorexia nervosa is a psychiatric diagnosis, and its treatment is impossible without a psychiatrist's involvement. What I will describe below is an attempt to understand how the diagnosis and its symptoms develop from a psychodynamic perspective.

Theoretical Framework: 5 Facts about Anorexia

Let's start with something simple to create context for the analysis:

1.   Gender Factor. The diagnosis of anorexia nervosa is 10 times more common among young women than among men. This points to the direct influence of gender and identification with the maternal figure. More precisely, to the impossibility of disidentifying with this figure (to separate, to reject the role model, to form one's own subjectivity). After all, being unlike one's parents is a challenge to them, an act of aggression and separation.

2.   Hysterical Reaction to the Body. Antonino Ferro notes that in some cases, patients want to lose even more weight because they see themselves as fat. But the psyche perceives not the body in the mirror, but affects related to its parts. Anorexic patients see their emotions in the mirror.

3.   Comorbidity and Idealness. This diagnosis often correlates with Bipolar Disorder, OCD, and hysteria. A characteristic feature is an excessive striving for idealness, which indicates an attraction to an idealized object, a fear of separation, and an inability to experience loss.

4.   Locked Hatred. The classical view associates anorexia with an incredible feeling of hatred within. The hatred is so great that there is an unconscious fear: «My rage could kill someone in reality».

5.   The Presence of Death. This diagnosis can lead to a fatal outcome, which is why Death is invisibly present in the field and in the psyche of both participants in the process.

«Chosen Fact»: The Lost Letter «I»

Next is my attempt to see the movement of affects through this case. I'll start with a fact that is personally key for me — it brings everything else together. This is the rejection of the letter «I» in the name.

In analysis, this is called a «chosen fact». The analyst always has many ideas, but a key is needed. It was the distortion of the name (an unconscious action by the analyst) that became such a key. Another aspect of the relationship is an attempt to extract the analyst's self from the analysand's self. I think this fact conceals two phenomena: an attempt to endow the girl with uniqueness and, at the same time, contempt for her, or perhaps even disgust.

Psychogenesis: The Divine Child and the Dead Mother

An analysis of scattered «clues» allows us to reconstruct the picture of the beginning of this girl's life.

The Fantasy of the Divine

I assume that this patient's mother very much anticipated this child, unconsciously endowing its image with something comparable to divinity. The woman wanted to give birth to an ideal child. Perhaps this was related to the child's gender, which allows us to assume some confusion of the mother herself with this girl. She wanted to reproduce in reality the boundless love that she herself needed.

«After birth, the mother and father explore their child's body, stroking it lovingly, squeezing its tiny hands and feet, examining its head, eyes, and ears, comparing it with their fantasies about the imagined child.»

— Gertrude Diem-Wille

Confrontation with Reality

But reality put everything in its place. An ordinary child was born — of flesh and blood, crying, sick, demanding. Perhaps this gave rise to an extreme conflict within the mother between divinity and ordinariness.

For some time, the girl might have felt this «divine attitude.» But at some point, the «effort to love» turned into depression. Instead of love in her mother's eyes, the infant began to see detachment. All of the mother's attention was now turned inward.

«This is not about depression from a real object loss... The main feature of this depression is that it develops in the presence of an object immersed in its own grief. <...> In any case, the mother's sadness and her decreased interest in the child are paramount.»

— André Green, «The Dead Mother»

Confusion of Time, Space, and Objects

My attention is drawn to the confusion at various levels of interaction with reality.

1.   Confusion in Time.

The girl attacks the setting. This can be linked to the inability to form a direct timeline. Some event leaves a trace in memory, and the child, thinking about the future, is actually remembering the past ("Memories of the Future" by G. Civitarese).

The little girl, expecting to feel happiness in her mother's arms, had to make a double "time leap": recall the past feeding, be disappointed, cancel it, and fly back to the previous, ideal one. This is like a dream within a dream.

2.   Confusion in Objects.

The girl often scheduled and canceled sessions. I think that when she scheduled a meeting, she felt she had found that Primary Loving Mother. But as the meeting time approached, reality overshadowed fantasy. She realized that she would meet a stranger. This led to a desire to destroy the scene of disappointment.

3.   Confusion in Space.

An infant does not perceive the mother as a separate subject. The omnipotent fantasy assumes perceiving the mother as part of oneself. The fantasy of a concave nipple and the ritual with the pill make one wonder: this patient, at some level, does not understand where their "inside" is — beyond the skin or outside.

"The mother's face can be considered the prototype of a mirror. In the maternal face, the child sees themselves. If the mother is suppressed, depressed, or preoccupied with something else, the child will only see the face."

— D. W. Winnicott

Summary

Of course, we will never hear such formulations from an anorexic patient. They do not need to know them at all. This entire psychoanalytic picture is needed by the analyst for interpretations, which in this case should be aimed at bringing order to the temporal, spatial, and object worlds.


References and Mentions

1.   Green, Andre. The Dead Mother (Narcissisme de vie, narcissisme de mort). The concept of the “dead mother complex.”

2.   Ferro, Antonino. Torments of the Soul (Torments of the Soul). Analysis of the phenomenon of anorexia and hysterical reaction to the body.

3.   Winnicott, D. W. Play and Reality. The concept of the mirroring role of the mother's face.

4.   Roussillon, René. Works on the metapsychology of symbolization processes (quote about the mother as the «only world»).

5.   Dim-Wille, Gertrud. Early Childhood. A Psychoanalytic Study of Development.

6.   Civitarese, Giuseppe. Works on the concept of time in psychoanalysis ("Memories of the Future").


Illustrations for the article:

  • Edvard Munch. "Separation"
  • Egon Schiele. "Mother and Child" (1912)

 

Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoЖеланиеДенис КуличковПсихоанализАнорексияРасстройство пищевого поведенияРПЛ
Views: 314

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!