No Actions Without Emotions, or Why Leaders Deny the Importance of Internal Transformation

Бизнес
Дана
Дана Янсон
21 мая 2026

Article narration

Loading…
No Actions Without Emotions, or Why Leaders Deny the Importance of Internal Transformation

Author: Dana Janson, PhD in Psychology, Founder of proEgo

The modern corporate world is accustomed to relying on strict logic, objectivity, and dry pragmatism. Rational thinking and well-calibrated strategies are considered the gold standard for business management. However, an obsession with absolute rationality creates a dangerous illusion: emotions begin to be perceived as an annoying hindrance — irrational noise that only "clutters" judgments and prevents a leader from acting objectively. Despite the confirmed benefits of high emotional intelligence, organizations often remain hostile to the inner world of feelings.

But this position is a colossus with feet of clay. Beyond formal business plans, there is a vast, hidden field of unconscious processes that must be taken into account. The eminent researcher of leadership psychology, Manfred Kets de Vries, in his book "The Leader on the Couch," articulates a fundamental truth: without feelings, there is no action. Without feelings, there is no passion, drive, or engagement. Everything that matters to us is dictated by emotions. And this is absolutely true not only for personal life but also for business.

The Myth of the "Rational Machine"

For generations, social sciences and management have desperately tried to elevate their prestige by pretending to be exact, natural sciences. Too many managers still view an organization as the living spirit of an economic machine, and employees as conscious, goal-oriented mechanisms.

We build strategies based on the model of homo economicus (the rational economic person). But the paradox is that at a conscious level, we can deny the existence of unconscious processes all we want, yet our ideal plans will be implemented by real homo sapiens — people subject to internal contradictory desires, fantasies, conflicts, defense mechanisms, and anxieties.

When the illusion of a rational mechanism completely displaces human reality, carefully developed concepts fail. And leaders are left with a vague sense of helplessness and ineffectiveness that defies their understanding.

A Case from Supervision: "The Iceberg of Managerial Sabotage"

To illustrate how unseen unconscious forces destroy ideal rational schemes, I will present a recent case from my supervision practice.

A colleague, working with the CEO and founder of a successful IT company (let's call him Vyacheslav), came to me for supervision.

  • Vyacheslav's Rational Request: The company needs to scale. To do this, he needs to hire top managers (C-level) and delegate operational management to them so that Vyacheslav himself can focus on global strategy.
  • Surface Reality: An expensive HR director was hired, ideal job descriptions were written, and brilliant candidates were found. But each time a new top manager started work, Vyacheslav would rigidly micromanage them, devalue their decisions, and meddle in the smallest processes. As a result, the top managers would resign after a couple of months. Vyacheslav sincerely complained: "There are no professionals in the market, no one wants to take responsibility, I have to carry everything myself again."

During supervision, we began to analyze not the company structure, but the personality of the CEO himself. Beneath the surface of "rational" explanations, we discovered a powerful unconscious conflict. At a conscious level, Vyacheslav wanted company growth. But at an unconscious level, delegation caused him a panic fear of losing control and losing his own identity. His entire self-esteem was built on the concept of "I am the irreplaceable savior of my business." If smart top managers came in and everything worked without him, who would he become?

His hidden anxiety sabotaged his own logical decisions. Until we brought this fear to a conscious level, no new regulations or organizational structure overhauls worked.

The Carpet Metaphor: Why Classic Management Doesn't Work

Manfred Kets de Vries offers a brilliant metaphor. Imagine a person trying to smooth out a bump on a carpet. He steps on it in one place, but the bump immediately appears in another. Many management researchers and business practitioners limit themselves to a mechanistic view: they only look at superficial manifestations — the bumps on the carpet — and try to "trample" the symptoms (employee turnover, missed deadlines, interdepartmental conflicts).

But to flatten the carpet, one needs to examine deeper structures. Too often, business agrees with the myth that only what we see and are aware of matters. But it is precisely what is hidden under the carpet (the leader's unconscious fears, the team's shadow dynamics) that determines a company's success or failure.

The Path to Organizational Health

Even the most successful organizational leaders are prone to highly irrational behavior, and this is a reality we ignore at our peril. By denying the reality of the unconscious, refusing to bring it to a conscious level and work with it, we create a chasm between reality and our perception of it.

What Should a Leader Do?

  1. Broaden your focus. Strict regulations and business processes show only the external shell. Learn to take into account hidden emotional motives — both your own and those of your organization's members.
  2. Analyze recurring scenarios. If, despite ideal plans, innovation implementation repeatedly fails in your company, or strong specialists regularly resign — stop trampling the "bump." Look for the cognitive and emotional distortions that trigger this cycle.
  3. Engage in internal transformation. Organizations cannot work successfully if leaders do not take into account the contingencies and irrational processes that are part of the team's inner world.

Because unconscious dynamics have a tremendous impact on business, leaders must be aware of them and account for them. That is why on the proEgo platform, we insist: comprehensive psychological support is not just about caring for the team climate, but a critically important management tool. Deep company transformation always begins with a leader's readiness to look beyond dry logic and confront their true feelings.

Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoДана ЯнсонВыгораниеКарьераУправление командойHRМенеджментБизнесЛидерствоУспехпсихолог для бизнесаПсихологПсихотерапияпсихотерапия для бизнесаwell-beingпсихологическая поддержка бизнеса (EAP)
Views: 421

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!