Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft in psychological practice
Article narration
Loading…Shake, but don't stir
Author: Dmitry Timofeev, Ph.D. in Psychology, proEgo platform psychologist
Author's Abstract
This is not a lecture. This is more of a fireside chat — about why it's vitally important for a child to have the right to want (and to make mistakes), and how toxic shame turns any 'give me' into 'how dare you.' We, psychologists, daily encounter clients who get stuck in double binds: 'If I ask, I'm bad; if I don't ask, I'm also bad.' Here we will look at this trap through two old sociological concepts — Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft. It turns out that many neuroses stem from confusing family with a corporation, and friendship with a legal process.
Two Systems Within Us: Meet Them
There are moments when we long for unconditional acceptance — like in childhood, when mom hugged just because. And there are moments when we need clarity: who owes what to whom, under what conditions, and what will happen if the conditions are not met.
Ferdinand Tönnies, a German sociologist (1860–1936), divided these states into two types of social ties:
-
Gemeinschaft — community, family, circle of 'one's own'. Values: unconditional belonging, forgiveness, care without negotiation. Here, a child can make a mistake — and won't be expelled. Here, people keep their word because 'it's shameful to let down one's own,' not because of a formal signature.
-
Gesellschaft — a society of contract, transaction, rational exchange. Values: formal rules, agreement, fair play. Here, trust is based on procedure: "you gave your word, you keep it, otherwise there will be sanctions." Here, you can lose in a competition, and it's not a blow to your personality, but simply a natural result.
Both systems are neither good nor bad. They are just different. The problem arises when we start to confuse them.
The cocktail metaphor
Imagine a cocktail. The ingredients combine, but remain distinguishable. If you shake them in a shaker, you get a harmonious mixture where you can taste both lemon and rum. But if you stir them into a homogeneous mush, the taste will disappear, becoming cloudy and nauseating. It's the same in life: we can be with our loved ones simultaneously in a Gemeinschaft (unconditional warmth) and in a Gesellschaft (agreement on who takes out the trash). But if we mix them into an indistinguishable mass, neuroses begin.
Where does the "perforation loop" come from? (Desire Trauma)
Let's be honest, many of our clients (and we ourselves once were) received not just a refusal in childhood. They were denied the right to want something. It sounds something like this: «No. And besides, how bad you are for even daring to ask». Or softer: «Aren't you ashamed? We do so much for you, and you...»
What's the trauma here? The child is forbidden not from an action — they are forbidden from the desire itself. And then a zone arises that can be called the perforation loop:
It's shameful to ask for acceptance — because if you ask, you confirm that you are a "bad asker." Better not to want at all. Or to want, but to remain silent. A defense arises: «I will lock myself away and look at you with contempt». This way, remnants of dignity are preserved — through passive aggression, distancing, and coldness.
Cycle of trauma development:
Ignoring ➔ Unspoken demand ➔ Punishment for the demand ➔ Withdrawal ➔ Contempt ➔ Anger ➔ Belief «the world is against me».
As a result, resentment forms — powerless malice that does not turn into action, but only whines: «You owe me, but I won't do anything because you won't give it anyway». In therapy, this looks like this: the client cannot ask to reschedule a session, but gets offended if the therapist is busy. Or doesn't say that they are hurt, and then disappears.
What a healthy Gemeinschaft can do
Paradox: it is precisely the Gemeinschaft, if it is healthy, that heals this loop. It provides a foundation — dignity as a gift, not as a reward for success. Values of a healthy community where one can be vulnerable:
-
You belong — simply because you exist. No need to prove your right to a place.
-
Forgiveness — an ordinary matter. No need to go through judgment to be accepted back.
-
Help — without bargaining. Care does not need to be earned.
-
Trust in advance. You are trusted before you prove anything.
-
Shame — a soft signal, not a club. To one who has stumbled, they say «let's think about how to fix it,» not «how could you not be ashamed».
-
Loss does not cancel belonging. You are still one of us, even if you lost today.
For the therapist, this is a checklist of what the client might have catastrophically lacked. And what can be gently offered in transference.
What a Healthy Gesellschaft Provides
Gesellschaft is about competition, about agon. But it only works if dignity is already given before the start. Otherwise, any defeat becomes an atomic bomb for self-esteem.
Rules of Fair Play for clients who fear competition:
-
Everyone starts from the same line. No advantage 'by acquaintance'.
-
A word once given (especially if signed) holds true.
-
The punishment is known in advance and is the same for everyone (no surprises).
-
Losing ≠ you are a bad person. It is simply the result of a specific game.
-
The game is played to the end. Even if you are losing 0:10.
-
After the match – a handshake. This is a ritual that says: "We part as equals, life goes on."
A nuance for practice: a client with a "loop of defeat" will avoid any competition. Give them an experience of safety: sign a humorous contract or play a board game by rules where the therapist can lose but not be destroyed. Seeing that losing doesn't kill the relationship, the client begins to breathe more freely.
The Dark Side: Betrayal of Gemeinschaft
Alas, community values can be turned inside out, transforming unconditional love into a trap of double binds (after G. Bateson):
-
"You are one of us, so you shouldn't want anything for yourself separately. If you do, you're selfish."
-
"We will forgive you if you admit you were wrong. And you were wrong for daring to ask at all."
-
"You can make mistakes, but we'll make sure you're ashamed of them."
In such a system, a person can neither stay nor leave. They get stuck in chronic shame. What should the therapist do? Legitimise the client's right to want and to make mistakes. Help them process grief: "Yes, your family betrayed what they promised — unconditional love. And that hurts." Anger will gradually turn to sadness, and then to the ability to negotiate.
Friendship — The "Up" Zone
Friendship is the most vibrant zone, where Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft don't blend into a mess, but rather are shaken up, creating a new flavor.
-
From Gemeinschaft: Unconditional acceptance, the right to make mistakes, shared rituals, and memory.
-
From Gesellschaft: Respect for boundaries («no» means no, and this doesn't break the connection), transparent agreements, fair play.
Many clients with attachment trauma are afraid of even simple agreements. They feel that any «let's agree» will kill the warmth. We can gently show: true friendship includes the ability to say «no».
A Practical Compass for the Therapist
| What the client says | What it signals | Direction of work (where to focus) |
| «If I ask for help, I'll be considered pushy. If I don't ask, I'll get offended and leave.» | Double-bind, double message trap | Articulate the message aloud. Ask: «What if you tried asking directly?» |
| "I can't lose — that will prove I'm nobody" | No inherent worth before the start of the "game" | Create a safe experience of losing/agon in the office, where relationships are maintained. |
| "I don't make arrangements with friends — they should understand on their own" | Bias towards Gemeinschaft, fear of Gesellschaft | Explore: "What if I just state my preferences? Will that truly kill the warmth?" |
| "I do everything by contract, but I feel cold and lonely" | Pure Gesellschaft without admixture of Gemeinschaft | Seek a place for unconditional acceptance (not just "I pay — you do", but also "how are you?"). |
Instead of a conclusion
We do not provide a recipe for "how to build relationships correctly". But we offer a tool — two lenses through which one can view many client (and personal) entanglements. If you feel stuck in shame for a desire, try asking yourself: "From whom do I currently seek acceptance — from someone who should give it unconditionally, or from someone who will give it by rules? Am I confusing game with love, and love — with contract?"
And most importantly: dignity is given before everything. You already have the right to desire, to make mistakes, and to lose. And not to stop being yourself because of it. Take care of yourselves and your clients.
- The article is based on a lively dialogue within the professional community. The author thanks a colleague who insisted on "shaking, not stirring," and everyone who read to this point.
From the editors: on the choice of illustration
To visually reinforce the ideas of this material, we chose one of the most recognizable paintings of the XX century — "Nighthawks" (1942) by Edward Hopper.
This work is arguably the most poignant visualization of what the article's author calls "pure Gesellschaft without a trace of Gemeinschaft." In Hopper's painting, we see people in extreme physical proximity to each other, in a single brightly lit space. They impeccably adhere to the rules of a "contract society": customers pay for coffee, the bartender performs their professional duties.
However, there isn't a shred of that communal warmth (Gemeinschaft), empathy, or genuine interest between them. Each character is locked in their invisible glass capsule of solitude. The painting perfectly illustrates the state of a "frozen" client: they may be successful, may masterfully adhere to agreements and maintain social distance, but at the same time, they are deeply unhappy due to the inability to break through this glass wall and ask for unconditional acceptance. The choice of this canvas is a reminder that without "shaking up" rules with living human warmth, any efficiency turns into cold isolation.
Sources and Recommended Reading
For those who wish to delve deeper into the topic:
-
Tönnies F. Community and Society (Gemeinschaft und Gesellschaft). — A classic of sociology. The introduction and chapter on basic concepts are recommended reading.
-
Bateson G. Steps to an Ecology of Mind. — Chapters on double bind and schizophrenia.
-
Scheler M. Ressentiment in the Structure of Morals. — Comprehensive look at powerless anger that doesn't translate into action.
-
Berne E. Games People Play. — Games "Kick Me" and "Why Don't You..." as excellent illustrations of the "kick me" cycle.
-
Rogers C. On Becoming a Person. A Therapist's View of Psychotherapy. — Chapters on unconditional positive regard as the foundation of dignity.
-
Nietzsche F. On the Genealogy of Morality. — The first essay on how the morality of ressentiment triumphs over the morality of agon.
-
Artemyeva A. (ed.) Shame and Guilt: Psychology, Culture, Therapy.
-
Kitchener C. Fair Play in Sport and Life. — On how rules protect the participant's dignity
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
