Group. Life in miniature

Психология
Денис
Денис Куличков
28 февраля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Group. Life in miniature

Humans are inherently social beings. Without the support of another psyche, a person cannot realize the potential for thought embedded in their body. It is enough to recall feral children who, even if integrated into normal society in childhood, still could not reach the level of psychological development of ordinary children. From the first second of life, a child must not only fall into warm and caring hands but also into the sphere of influence of someone else's psychic apparatus.

From this moment, everything that happens to the child is directed towards the environment in which they are, with the sole purpose of having that environment, primarily including the mother, help them cope with overwhelming experiences. Traces of how our infantile anxieties were processed or not processed by those around us are reflected in all subsequent anxious states and in all relationships with other people. Especially with people who are emotionally significant to us. This applies to our romantic relationships, friendships, and work relationships.

Our ability to establish a quality connection with the emotional life of a group determines how we will feel and behave within it. This, in turn, directly impacts the realization of our personal potential.

The smallest group of people imaginable in its common understanding is two individuals. However, the psychoanalytic view of this concept implies that a person never ceases to be part of a group. Even when alone, they continue to think as a group member, distinct from its other parts. This allows us to conclude that a person's ability to effectively interact with a group extends its influence to the inner psychological well-being of each individual.

"Anyone who joins a group for therapy or personal development embarks on a journey. Although the journey can be described in different ways, various approaches to 'travel notes' are based on the same principle. What the group does for the individual is related to what the individual does in and for the group. The processes of growth and change work only if they occur in both directions."

— John R. Shlapobersky

A Place for Growth

Undoubtedly, whether a person develops or regresses within a group depends on the specific group they are in. One group may be beneficial for them, while another may harm them. A group that allows one individual to progress may lead to another's regression. The main difficulty is that in everyday life, finding a group suitable for one's development can be very challenging. Moreover, any group, functioning as a single organism, can change significantly after new participants join, as happens, for example, in work teams.

A therapeutic group, in this sense, is somewhat the opposite:

  • Placement: All participants in group therapy undergo a brief interview for placement into suitable groups.

  • Rules: The group adheres to certain rules, which makes it more predictable.

  • Facilitator: The group has a facilitator who understands the group processes unfolding within it and helps participants cope with the feelings, situations, and phenomena that emerge in the group. Without this, the group might go astray.

What Science Says

Research data convincingly confirms the power of the group format:

  • A meta-analysis of 48 studies (n = 2,218 participants) showed that 45 out of 48 works confirmed the effectiveness of group therapy for depression. When compared to no treatment, the effect size was 1.026 at the end of therapy and increased to 1.178 during catamnestic follow-up — meaning the result not only persisted but also strengthened over time.

  • A large-scale prospective study of short-term outpatient group psychotherapy showed that 76.3% of participants achieved their therapeutic goals , with efficacy being independent of age, gender, baseline anxiety, or depression levels.

  • An updated meta-analysis (Cuijpers et al.) and data from Burlingame et al. demonstrated that group psychotherapy is statistically comparable to individual therapy in its outcomes , and in some randomized studies, it surpasses individual therapy in terms of long-term stability of changes.

Counter-Group

Why, then, might a group, convened to achieve therapeutic goals, begin to act contrary to them? To answer this question, we need to touch upon the concept of groupthink.

The fact is that at some point, group members unconsciously begin to project their psychotic parts into the psychic space formed by all participants, and these parts begin to live a life of their own. This can lead to the group starting to assign destructive roles to participants, as well as acting against itself or its leader. This occurs because the collective can be taken over by those very clusters of unprocessed psychic parts of its members, which have merged into a single emotional field. Such phenomena have been termed «basic assumptions».

At their core, these assumptions are counterproductive and aim to prevent the group from fulfilling its primary task. Such assumptions arise not only in psychotherapeutic groups but are also relevant for ordinary work groups. Moreover, a therapeutic group participant will gravitate towards the same functioning and roles that they enact in everyday life and in daily work groups. Thus, the therapeutic group allows for the identification and understanding of destructive or paralyzing aspects of its participants' psyche.

One such assumption is the basic assumption of dependency. A group susceptible to this phenomenon holds the belief that someone, upon whom the group fully relies, must completely satisfy all its needs and desires. That is, according to the group members, an object exists within its reach whose task is to ensure its safety, as if caring for an «immature organism».

Such a group will seek a leader to place the responsibility for achieving its goals upon them. This leader can be either a group member or the therapist. After appointing such a leader, the group behaves as if all its outcomes depend solely on their actions. It goes without saying that no one benefits from such a distribution of roles: neither the appointed leader nor the other participants.

It's important to mention that such role distributions occur with the participation of all group members. And only an analysis of group activity helps understand precisely how each participant influenced what happened.

«One Tuesday morning, no one spoke a word for the entire 90-minute session. We all literally sat in silence, listening to the rumble of the subway below, the screech of car brakes, the clang of a door slammed shut by someone in the corridor. We didn't catch each other's eyes or giggle. In the first half of the session, I picked lint off my sweater, jiggled my foot, and fiddled with my cuticles. Every thirty seconds, I looked at the clock. The silence made me feel exposed, anxious, and unproductive.»

— Christie Tate

Why is this awareness important?

One of the paradoxes that a person may notice in relationships with others is that in a collective, something seems to bind them, their abilities diminish, and they become partially helpless. A smart, sensible person suddenly gets lost in a crowd and not only cannot express their thoughts but loses the ability to reason. Conversely, someone else transforms from a calm, shy person into an aggressor attempting to force others to obey. The first loses the ability to realize their potential, the second spoils relationships with colleagues or friends.

In a therapeutic group, a person can understand the reasons for their particular manifestations. Are they caused by conflict with the group or by contributing to its basic assumption? In this sense, a psychodynamic group is an ideal place to «catch oneself in the act»: to see exactly how a person gives up their opportunities, where they agree to play the role of «small,» «invisible,» or «omnipotent,» and how this affects relationships, career, and family.

What does the therapist observe?

Observing a person in a group provides something that cannot be achieved with tests, questionnaires, or even the most insightful individual conversation. There is much more information in a group — it's not just a person's inner world, there are relationships. This means it becomes clear how this inner world unfolds outwards.

  • First and foremost, the language of the participants comes into the analyst's view. What specific words a person chooses, how their language affects the group, and how the participant adopts the gradually forming language of the group.

  • What distance do group participants choose?

  • What pairs or coalitions do they form?

  • Is the group capable of providing support, or is it formed to demand?

  • Are egalitarian relationships possible in the group, or does hierarchy and dependence prevail?

An important aspect of the sessions is also the identification of the dominant anxieties of the session. By grasping this phenomenon, one can understand what the group and its participants are struggling against. What are they afraid of?

In later stages, the group can turn to creativity. This is the most fruitful stage of work. However, not every group is ready to create, overcoming its envy and destructiveness. Concurrently, the group finds its identity, and with it, acknowledges and supports the individuality of its members. All of this may or may not happen. And if it does happen, the group has a synergistic effect. Overall progress is not a matter of simple addition — it's more like a vigorous chemical reaction that exponentially enhances the quality of the group's functioning as a separate organism.

«As soon as Stella joined the group, her problems immediately manifested. She was shy and depressed, but she spoke breathlessly and couldn't stop. She was an artist and a teacher. She said that she had returned home to her apartment two months ago and was settling in again. She resumed teaching at the art college and even returned to painting in her studio. During her first sessions, she did not answer questions about where she had been before. By the fifth meeting, she had found a way to speak without overwhelming herself, and could sit quietly and listen without undue agitation.»

— John R. Schlapobersky

Stages of Therapeutic Group Development

Any therapeutic group is a journey, and everyone who joins it embarks on a path. What the group does for the individual is inseparable from what the individual does in and for the group: growth is possible only when movement goes both ways. The group has no externally given direction; its true purpose is to discover its own authenticity, to find the «true self» of each participant and of the group as a whole.

Many authors describe group development in stages. By combining Tuckman's ideas and therapists' clinical observations, several stages can be conditionally identified:

  1. Formation — participants observe each other, try to appear «decent», and hide their most painful areas. Inclusion anxiety dominates: «Will they accept me? Is there a place for me?»

  2. Conflict and Tumult — real differences surface, conflicts, competition, and resistance arise. The first strong affects appear, testing the boundaries of the therapist and the group.

  3. Normalization and Consolidation — group culture gradually forms: it becomes safer to talk about feelings, trust increases, and participants take more responsibility for their own contribution.

  4. Creativity and Productivity — the group reaches a level where deep self-exploration and exploration of others are possible, leading to complex insights, and more mature forms of intimacy and separation.

  5. Completion — experiencing farewells, integrating experiences, transferring newfound ways of being with people into daily life.

And all of this is done together. It is much easier to go through pain shoulder to shoulder, provided the safety of this space is maintained.

«By the time of completion, the group already carries within itself the stories of its participants, and saying goodbye is rarely neutral. Each person takes away not only their own changes but also the experience that their inner world was once held by another field — the field of the group.»

In conclusion, it's worth saying that it's never too late to become happy, but almost always it means learning to be with people differently than before. The group offers a rare opportunity to see exactly how a person currently interacts with others, and together with others, move step by step towards what these relationships could be.

Sign up for the group in the profile or via the link https://proego.com/groups/eecf73c7-a4d9-4f38-816a-10f50294ee4a


References:

  1. McDermut, W., Miller, I. W., & Brown, R. A. (2001). The Efficacy of Group Psychotherapy for Depression: A Meta-analysis and Review of the Empirical Research. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 8(1), 98–116.

  2. Tschuschke, V., Crameri, A., Koehler, M., Berglar, J., Muth, C. G., Staczan, P., von Wyl, A., Schulthess, P., & Bänninger-Huber, E. (2010). The role of therapists' treatment adherence, professional experience, therapeutic alliance, and clients' severity of psychological problems: Prediction of treatment outcome in a large scale naturalistic study. Psychotherapy Research, 20(4), 483–504.

  3. Cuijpers, P., van Straten, A., Andersson, G., & van Oppen, P. (2008). Psychotherapy for depression in adults: A meta-analysis of comparative outcome studies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 76(6), 909–922. / Burlingame, G. M., Strauss, B., & Joyce, A. S. (2013). Change mechanisms and effectiveness of small group treatments. In M. J. Lambert (Ed.), Bergin and Garfield's handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change (6th ed., pp. 640–689). John Wiley & Sons.

Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoПсихоанализгрупповая психотерапияДенис КуличковГруппа
Views: 406

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!