I want to hear you - analytical listening

Психология
Денис
Денис Куличков
7 марта 2026

Article narration

Loading…
I want to hear you - analytical listening

The main professional concern that worries me right now is how to differentiate between three types of meanings that may be contained in a client's speech, and how to formulate a response so that its meaning reaches precisely the instance from which it was sent.

Let's take a simple phrase that a person might say in the office:

“When I was 10, I got very sick. I couldn't eat, I had painful injections, and I became so weak that I couldn't move on my own. Since my parents worked during the day, my grandmother took care of me. But, it seems, she did it somewhat reluctantly.”

Let's imagine that the person saying this has been in analysis for some time. They are partly accustomed to the analyst and the work format, can think relatively freely, and at least sometimes speak without censorship about whatever comes to mind. They don't try to adhere to a narrative line but rather float on the border of thinking, remembering, and semi-sleep.

The Historical Register and Neurobiology of Memory

Of course, the first register of what is said presents us with a narrative in a historical context. The person is simply telling us about their childhood memories. But the question arises: why does this particular memory become accessible and articulated at this specific moment?

If we rely on neuroscience, the phenomenon of spreading activation comes to mind. This is a process in the brain where the excitation of one memory “node” leads to the activation of associated neural ensembles in various brain regions. This allows us to rephrase the question: what caused those memory neurons connected to the articulated memory to “light up” precisely now?

Antonino Ferro, building on Wilfred Bion's ideas about the psychoanalytic field, suggests that we listen to the person in the office from three perspectives: historical, intrapsychic, and interpsychic.

The Intrapsychic Register: The Theatre of Internal Objects

From the perspective of describing intrapsychic activity, a person, while telling us about their illness, brings several internal objects onto the stage at once:

  • Helpless, abandoned «Self»;

  • Attacking bad objects (injections);

  • Absent good objects, whose reliability is doubted (parents and grandmother).

If we listen at this level, the original phrase about childhood illness sounds different to us:

«I'm not sure how I truly feel about the people I love. And because of this, I don't know who I truly am. This makes me freeze in helplessness».

Interpsychic register: here and now

From the perspective of describing interpsychic interaction (the interpsychic register), we should perceive the analysand's words as a metaphor describing what is happening right now in the consulting room.

In such a case, the person might be telling us that during the current or previous sessions, they perceived the analyst's interventions as painful (injections), which made them doubt how well the analyst felt about them (a grandmother caring «without desire»). In this field, the client's communication transforms into the following meaning:

«I came to you with my pain and expected you to treat me with great empathy. Your interpretations and questions hurt me too much. I conclude that for you, I am merely a job».

Communication Errors and Frustration

As you can see, a simple phrase can have many meanings. Responding to the client in the wrong modality will inevitably lead to a communication breakdown. Personal observation confirms this.

Indeed, sometimes, by perceiving what is said exclusively in a historical context and responding to the client precisely in a historical modality, we encounter a failure. For instance, an analyst, failing to grasp a deeper (interpsychic) meaning, says:

«What was the hardest for you then: pain, helplessness, or this feeling of her unwillingness?»

The client replies something, and after a while states: «It's a bit chilly in here today». Or perhaps they attack in a more active form. This indicates that despite the person opposite continuing the historical line (giving an answer from the conscious part of their psyche), they feel a breakdown in communication. Some part of them is frustrated at that moment because they were not truly heard.

Conclusion

Of course, the success of communication at any of these levels depends not only on the analyst but also on their interlocutor. This arduous task cannot be entirely and completely placed on one side of the analytical field.

But this is no reason to abandon the continuous development of therapeutic ability: to grasp the leading meaning, to gather the raw ingredients brought by the client, and to return to them a palatable dish, be it breakfast, lunch, or dinner.


List of Recommended Literature (from the editorial board):

  1. Ferro, A. (2007). Technique in Psychoanalysis: Child and Adult.

  2. Ferro, A. (2003). Psychoanalysis: Creating Stories.

  3. Bion, W. R. (2008). Learning Through Experience.

  4. Anderson, J. R. (1983). A spreading activation theory of memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior

  5. The main illustration used is John Bond Francisco's painting «The Sick Child» (1893). This canvas serves as an accurate visual metaphor for multidimensional analytical listening. The physical presence but emotional detachment of the caregiver (her gaze completely absorbed in knitting) brilliantly illustrates the analysand's frustration described in the text, encountering a «good» but unavailable object.
Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoПсихоанализНейробиологияНейропсихоанализСмыслЭмоцииДенис Куличков
Views: 460

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!