How to regulate the market for psychological services? The principle of "Do no harm"
Article narration
Loading…Analysis of Global Experience and a Digital Model for Russia
Author: Dana Vladimirovna Yanson
Candidate of Psychological Sciences, practicing psychotherapist, founder and CEO of the online psychotherapy platform proEgo
The discussion around draft laws on psychological assistance in Russia has reached its peak. Recently, commenting on the 'Psychological Newspaper' portal on the official review of one of the latest legislative initiatives by the Government of the Russian Federation, I promised to prepare a detailed analysis of how a modern legal framework can be built based on international experience. This material is the fulfillment of that promise.
After the rejection of previous initiatives, the professional community and regulators found themselves at a crossroads. On the one hand, leaving the market in a 'wild west' state is no longer possible: practice has scaled, over 80–90% of the private sector has moved online, and large digital ecosystems and aggregators have formed. On the other hand, the key rhetorical imperative of the legislator today is 'Do no harm'. Excessive administrative barriers, ill-conceived financial levies, or an attempt to force the industry into the patterns of the mid-last century will inevitably push thousands of conscientious specialists into the gray area.
To construct workable legislation, we need to compare the current legal vacuum in Russia with the existing laws of its closest neighbors (Belarus and Kazakhstan), as well as with global practices in mental health regulation.
1. Near Abroad: Conservative Vertical vs. Digital Breakthrough
A comparative legal analysis of the regulatory acts of Belarus and Kazakhstan clearly demonstrates two opposing approaches to industry regulation.
Experience of the Republic of Belarus: Conservative Offline Model
Law of the Republic of Belarus No. 153-Z (as amended on 30.06.2022) operates exclusively with the term 'psychological assistance', strictly subordinating the industry to the state vertical (Ministry of Health, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Emergency Situations).
- Pros: The law retained personnel in the profession who underwent professional retraining based on higher education, and regulated the rules for waiving psychological confidentiality in socially dangerous situations.
- Cons: The law is completely 'blind' to digital reality. It contains no mention of online platforms, remote therapy, or the protection of personal data online. The complete disregard for the commercial nature of paid services makes it difficult to apply consumer protection legislation when providing low-quality services.
Experience of the Republic of Kazakhstan: A Bold Step into the Digital Age
Kazakhstan Law No. 332-VIII, signed on July 2, 2026, is an example of modern legal adaptation.
- Legislative Breakthrough: Kazakhstan has officially legalized the term "non-medical psychotherapy", resolving a long-standing conflict between psychologists and psychiatrist-doctors.
- Digital Integration: The law introduces a separate article regulating the operation of online platforms, mandatory registration of specialists in a digital State Register, and the legality of confidentiality waiver in cases of suicidal risks.
2. European Vector: GDPR, EU AI Act, and the Institute of Professional Liability
The European Union has been building the regulation of psychotherapy and mental health for decades. Its experience provides us with three crucial guidelines that should be considered in the Russian draft law:
A. Protection of Special Category Data
In accordance with Article 9 of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), information on mental health and transcripts of psychotherapy sessions are considered "special categories of personal data." In Europe, the use of ordinary commercial messengers (WhatsApp, Zoom) for therapy outside secure certified circuits incurs fines of up to €20 million. European practice requires full data depersonalization and storage of audio/video streams in isolated encrypted environments.
B. AI Regulation in Mental Health (EU AI Act 2024)
The EU Artificial Intelligence Act classifies AI systems used in healthcare and for analyzing human emotional states as high-risk (High-Risk AI Systems). Europe strictly prohibits the autonomous operation of "AI therapists." Only "AI assistants" under mandatory human supervision (Human-in-the-loop) are permitted, requiring separate informed consent from the user for machine processing of voice and text.
C. Financial Protection through Liability Insurance (EuroPsy / Germany / Austria)
European countries (for example, within the framework of the German Psychotherapeutengesetz) do not compel specialists to pay large contributions to SRO compensation funds. Instead, a mandatory condition for private practice is professional liability insurance (Berufshaftpflichtversicherung). If a specialist causes moral or psychological harm to a client, the insurance company assumes responsibility for compensation payments.
3. Russian Context: How to Resolve Conflicts and Incorporate Best International Practices
Current Russian draft laws (drafts by N. Ostanina, A. Kuznetsova, S. Avksentyeva) have reached an impasse due to attempts to combine incompatible legal norms. A team of lawyers, psychologists, and IT specialists at proEgo have developed a comprehensive model that integrates international experience into the current legal framework of the Russian Federation without creating new conflicts.
1. Distinction: "Psychological Aid" vs. "Paid Service"
- Problem: The attempt to describe the commercial market using the language of social "aid" creates a conflict with the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.
- Solution: Introduce a strict two-tier separation.
- Level A ("Aid"): state sector (schools, EMERCOM, social services).
- Level B ("Service"): market sector. Paid consultations should be regulated by Chapter 39 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation (Remunerated provision of services) and the Law "On Protection of Consumer Rights". This will give clients legal rights to quality and refunds, and platforms the legal right to implement quality regulations.
2. Legalization of "Non-medical Psychotherapy"
- Problem: The term "psychotherapy" is blocked by the Ministry of Health (Federal Law No. 323-FZ). Thousands of highly qualified psychologists, proficient in evidence-based methods (CBT, psychoanalysis, gestalt), are forced to work in a grey area.
- Solution: Following Kazakhstan's example, officially introduce the term "Non-medical psychotherapy". Access to it should be granted to specialists with higher education or retraining (from 500 hours) plus completion of specialized method training (300 - 500 hours), personal therapy, and supervision. This will address the Ministry of Health's concerns, as psychologists do not claim to provide pharmacotherapy or treatment for severe mental pathologies.
3. Synchronization with the Law "On Platform Economy" (Federal Law No. 289-FZ)
- Problem: The regulator requires IT platforms ("proxy controllers") to verify specialists, but IT companies lack the competence to assess professional education.
- Solution: solidify the status of "Operator of a Digital Psychological Platform". The platform undertakes automatic verification of diplomas through integration with the FRDO (Federal Register of Education Documents) before allowing a specialist to work. Platforms become a natural technical quality filter.
4. Digital SROs and Insurance Instead of Contributions
- Problem: traditional SROs with large contributions to compensation funds will bankrupt 90% of self-employed psychologists and cause a mass exodus of specialists into the shadows.
- Solution: creation of Digital SROs. Abolition of compensation funds and transition to mandatory professional liability insurance (a policy costing 5–8 thousand rubles per year). This guarantees financial protection for the client within the framework of the Law on Consumer Rights Protection and does not create barriers for self-employed individuals.
5. Digital Professional Passport and Supervision Record Keeping
- Problem: legislators do not understand how to administer supervision hours without inflating the bureaucratic staff.
- Solution: introduction of a "Digital Professional Passport", integrated with "Gosuslugi" (Unified System of Identification and Authentication). Platforms maintain an automatic "digital log of supervisions" and transmit anonymized confirmed hours to the State Register via API.
Summary Matrix of Solutions for the New Russian Federation Bill
|
Criterion |
Conservative Approach (Belarus) |
Kazakh Breakthrough |
European Experience |
Model for Russia (proEgo) |
|
Market Status |
Only «Help» (ignores business) |
Help considering online platforms |
Separation of clinical help and commercial service |
Level A (Help) / Level B (Service under Russian Civil Code and Law on Consumer Protection)
|
|
Psychotherapy |
Term is absent for psychologists |
«Non-medical psychotherapy» established
|
Medical and psychological psychotherapy separated |
Introduction of «Non-medical psychotherapy» (300-500h method)
|
|
Digital Platforms |
Not regulated (offline only) |
Separate article on online platforms |
Regulated as digital operators |
Status of «Digital Platform Operator» + 289-FZ
|
|
Data Protection and AI |
Basic confidentiality norms |
General IT legislation |
GDPR (art. 9) + EU AI Act (High-Risk AI) |
Encrypted circuits + AI assistants under FZ-152
|
|
Financial Protection |
Absent |
State Certification |
Mandatory liability insurance |
Mandatory liability insurance (5-8 thousand rubles/year)
|
|
Supervision Control |
Not in law |
Fixed in law |
Mandatory CPD / Supervision hours |
"Digital supervision log" with data transfer via API
|
Summary: The Time for Pragmatic Consolidation
The main conclusion we must draw from the analysis of international practice is: regulation cannot be built contrary to technological progress and economic realities.
The market for psychological services is already formed, digitized, and operates 90% online. Any attempt to regulate it with methods of direct prohibition or bureaucratic levies will only lead to legal paralysis. A bill that truly protects citizens and allows professionals to develop must be digital, hybrid, and based on liability insurance.
Taking this opportunity, I publicly address the authors of the current draft laws and representatives of the relevant committees of the State Duma: we are open to dialogue and collaboration. I urge the inclusion of proEgo platform experts in the relevant working group. We are ready to provide our technological infrastructure, analytics, and international experience to collectively create a modern, effective law that unites the academic experience of associations, the capabilities of state digital services (ESIA, FRDO), and the expertise of IT platforms. Only in this way can we build one of the most advanced and secure legal ecosystems for mental health.
*The cover image for this article was generated by the OpenIA neural network
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
