The Cult of Leadership and Its Shadow
Article narration
Loading…In modern HR discourse, the term "leadership qualities" has long turned into a fetish. Open any job vacancy – from marketing director to junior analyst – and you will almost certainly see "proactivity", "ability to lead others", and "leadership potential" in the requirements. The labor market is obsessed with finding "alpha players".
As a psychoanalyst and business founder, I observe this arms race with professional skepticism. We fetishize the facade of leadership – charisma, assertiveness, ambition – often ignoring its unconscious underside.
Business is not just about breakthroughs, but also about maintaining positions. It is a complex organism that needs not only "heads", but also "hands", "livers", and "hearts". If every cell in the organism decides to become a "head", the system will die.
In this article, I propose to look at a candidate's leadership potential through the lens of depth psychology and answer an uncomfortable question: when does a bright leader in a team become not a locomotive, but that very "bone in the throat" capable of strangling established processes?
Anatomy of a leader: a psychoanalytic view
What are we actually looking for when we seek a "leader"? In psychoanalytic terms, we are looking for a person with a specific psychic structure.
Healthy leadership is based on "healthy narcissism". This is the fuel that allows a person to desire more, withstand competition, take responsibility and, critically, cope with narcissistic injuries (defeats) without destroying their Self. Such a leader is able to invest their energy not only in themselves, but also in the "Cause" – in the company, in the product, in the team, perceiving them as a narcissistic extension of themselves.
However, the line between healthy and pathological narcissism is very thin. A pathological leader uses the company solely as a stage for acting out their unconscious scenarios – most often, an insatiable thirst for recognition and power, compensating for a deep sense of inferiority.
For an HR director and owner, it is critically important to distinguish between these two types at the hiring stage. The first will build, the second will use and then destroy.
When leadership is vital: chaos and creation
Leadership qualities (high energy level, aggression in a constructive sense, tolerance for uncertainty) are absolutely necessary in situations where there is no structure.
1. Startup and Rapid Growth Stage.
When there are no rules, they must be created. This stage requires a person capable of enduring immense anxiety of uncertainty and containing (digesting) the team's anxiety.
Example from international practice: early Uber.
If you look at Travis Kalanick in the early days of Uber. His aggressive, assertive leadership style, bordering on an ethical foul, was psychodynamically necessary for the company to break the resistance of regulators and taxi companies worldwide. At that moment, the company needed a «berserker» capable of ignoring obstacles. This was a stage of fighting for survival.
proEgo's personal experience:
When I was creating the proEgo platform, we were in a zone of high turbulence. We needed to convince the conservative professional psychotherapeutic community of the safety and ethics of the online format, while simultaneously building complex IT processes. For key managerial positions during that period, I was looking for people with a pronounced «leadership radical» — those who didn't wait for instructions, but were ready to dig into problems and impose their will on chaos. A purely executive person at that moment would have simply «burned out» from the level of anxiety.
2. Crisis Management and Transformation.
When an old structure dies, a «surgeon» is needed, capable of taking the blame for unpopular decisions. This is also a leadership function — the ability to withstand projections of aggression from the team.
When Leadership is a «Bone in the Throat»: Stability and Function
The most costly mistake is to hire a bright leader for a position that requires a function of support, stabilization, or deep narrow expertise in an already established system.
If you hire a person with a powerful leadership drive into a stable department with strict regulations, you will not get a «star». You will get unconscious sabotage.
Why? Because for a person with a narcissistic leader structure, submitting to rules that they did not create is perceived as humiliation. In psychoanalytic terms, this activates the Oedipal conflict — unconscious rivalry with the «Paternal figure» (represented by the manager, company regulations, or the owner themselves).
Such an employee will begin to:
- Undermine existing processes ("all this is outdated, I know better").
- Compete with their direct supervisor instead of empowering them.
- Form coalitions and split the team.
Example from international practice: Mature corporations (e.g., Toyota or IBM during periods of stability).
In companies with a culture of gradual improvements (e.g., Kaizen at Toyota) or strict hierarchy, the appearance of a "rock star" seeking immediate revolution and personal glory disrupts the delicate fabric of team interaction. The system either rejects such an individual, or they begin to destroy the system from within, attempting to rebuild it "for themselves" not for efficiency, but to confirm their own significance.
Case from the supervisory practice of the proEgo Expert Council:
The situation was brought for supervision by the HR director of a large manufacturing company (a platform client).
A candidate with a brilliant background in aggressive consulting was hired for the position of Deputy Finance Director in a stable, well-functioning finance department. At the interview, he charmed everyone with his "burning eyes" and ambition.
Dynamics: within three months, the department's work was paralyzed. The new deputy did not integrate into processes but tried to immediately reshape them. He openly (and often skillfully) criticized his superior — the finance director, a woman with vast experience but a gentle management style. He "devoured" her authority, unconsciously trying to take the "main" position. The team split into those charmed by the "revolutionary" and those who wanted to work calmly.
Analysis: The company hired a "warrior" for the role of "guardian of the hearth." His psychic energy found no outlet in direct competition with the external market and turned inward, becoming corporate auto-aggression. This is a classic example of a "bone in the throat" — his leadership potential was destructive for this particular coordinate system.
Diagnostics for HR and Top Management
How can you distinguish, during an interview, someone who will strengthen a business from someone who will blow it up? In-depth diagnostics take time, but there are markers worth paying attention to.
- Attitude towards authority and boundaries.
Ask about past managers. A pathological leader always devalues "former" ones. A healthy leader is capable of seeing the strengths and weaknesses of others; they are capable of gratitude. If a candidate cannot acknowledge the authority of another, they will never be a team player in secondary roles.
- Ability to be 'second'.
The greatest leadership quality is the ability to follow an idea or a person who is, at a given moment, more important for the common goal. Ask a projective question: "In what situation are you willing to submit to a decision you internally disagree with, for the good of the team?" A true leader knows the answer. A narcissist does not.
- Contact with reality vs. grandiosity.
Listen to how the candidate talks about achievements. Do they use 'we' or only 'I'? Are they capable of admitting failures? A leader without contact with the reality of their limitations is a ticking time bomb.
Conclusion
We must move away from a simplistic understanding of leadership as a universal good. Businesses do not need a team composed solely of leaders, but rather a healthy psychological ecosystem.
The task of a mature manager and HR director is not just to hire the "best," but to delicately fine-tune the team's psychodynamics. Sometimes, the best candidate for a position is one whose leadership ambitions are "quieter" and whose capacity for integration and support is higher.
Before looking for a "star," ask yourself: is your system ready to digest their energy, or is this energy directed towards destroying what you have built for so long?
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
