Invisible Hand

Философия жизни
Дмитрий
Дмитрий Тимофеев
14 февраля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Invisible Hand

Have you ever noticed how this world is structured? You walk down a corridor, ahead is a door. You hold it open for the person coming after you. They say "thank you." It takes a second. Costs nothing. Is recorded nowhere.

But if you imagine that such seconds suddenly ceased to exist — all of them, everywhere — the world would turn into hell. This is not an exaggeration. This is not a metaphor. This is a literal description of how people become people at all.


First, there was "You" (formal)

There's an old philosophical framework that Martin Buber explored in detail. The world is divided into "I," "Thou," and "It."

●      "It" — a thing that can be used.

●      "Thou" — a loved one, a close one, one of your own.

But what about a stranger in line? A person who follows you into the subway? There's no place for them in this framework. But they exist.

And this is where the "You" (formal) modus arises. It's not "Thou" (intimacy) and not "It" (utilization). It's relating to another as an equal participant in a shared world. We don't know them. We don't love them. We simply acknowledge their existence.

 

To hold the door means to say: "I see you." To let someone in a hurry pass means: "Your time is no less valuable than mine." To nod in response to a question means: "You are not nothing."

 

Social Glue vs. Documents

It's often said nowadays: society relies on documents. Contracts, laws, digital footprints. But a door held open leaves no record. A smile to a cashier vanishes in the same second.

These are pure social acts. They live only in the moment of their execution. But try to remove them all — and you get an incubator. Sterile, functional, deadly. Documents create the framework. And micro-gestures create the glue. Without the glue, the framework falls apart. This is what Erving Goffman called "the presentation of self to others" — the fabric of everyday life.


Five steps from which a person grows

If recognition has happened, if contact has been established — then the assembly of personality begins. Drawing on the ideas of Mikhail Papush and Paul Ricœur, one can distinguish the trajectory of this growth:

1.     Recognition. The admission ticket. Someone said, "you exist." Without this primary "yes," no career can fill the void.

2.     Attachment. The contact begins to be energized. The part of you that lives in these relationships gets a "body" — emotional and alive.

3.     Role. The contact gets a name. "I am a friend," "I am a mentor." A role is not a prison, but an outline. It makes us legible.

4.     Responsibility. A part of you matures. It stops only taking — it starts giving. You exist because you are needed.

5.     Mimesis (Imitation). The most challenging step. We begin to see reflections of great role models in ourselves. We try on their way of being.


The Trap of the Neighbor. René Girard and Mimetic Desire

The "You" mode is a great achievement. But in the sphere of "neighbors" (family, colleagues, friends), it falters. This is where the space of unbearable comparison begins.

French philosopher René Girard asked a devastating question: why do people who have everything continue to desire what belongs to others?

Girard's answer: Human desire is fundamentally imitative (mimetic).

We are not born with a list of what we need. We look at another person and say: "They want something. That means it has value. I want it too."

In this scheme, there are always three:

1.     Subject (I).

2.     Object of desire.

3.     Role Model (Mediator) — the one who indicates what to desire.

Girard turns everything upside down: we don't want the thing itself — we want to be the one who wants it. We want to adopt another person's very being, their fullness and confidence.

Why one's neighbor is a threat

When I imitate another's desire, I inevitably come into conflict with them. We want the same thing. The more I imitate, the more I become a copy, and a copy threatens the original.

One's neighbor is not a stranger or an enemy. It is someone whose desire I read as a command. Someone who becomes both my model and my obstacle at the same time.


The Scapegoat as a World Machine

A Roman ritual sacrifice. An illustration of how collective violence (the killing of a victim) becomes a sacred act that unites society and establishes order.

How to maintain peace if the very structure of desire generates rivalry? Girard gives a terrible answer in the book "Violence and the Sacred".

The only way to stop a chain reaction of aggression is to redirect it to one person. To find a "Scapegoat". Someone who will be blamed for everything.

When the crowd unanimously expels the victim, peace ensues. The victim is innocent, but their expulsion restores order. This is how culture, rituals, and prohibitions arise. We do not know how to reconcile otherwise.


The Way Out: Honest Mimesis

Girard does not simply suggest "becoming kinder". He offers a perspective. Envy, resentment, bullying in a collective — these are not random breakdowns, but the very fabric of human desire.

But there is a way out. It lies in the awareness of the fifth step (Mimesis).

Imitation is inevitable. Without it, there is no learning or culture. But we can choose a Model:

●      You can imitate a rival, focusing on the race.

●      You can imitate a model that opens the way to freedom.

As Mikhail Papush writes, the task is to see your subpersonalities and their models. The question is not to stop imitating, but to choose a model consciously.


Conclusion. Ontology of Politeness

The world begins with small things. A person who has gained worldwide fame but is deprived of daily human affirmation is unhappy.

Therefore, the next time you hold the door, know that you have performed an ontological act. You said "you are" — and at that moment, you yourself became a little more. The subject is born not in solitude, but in the gap between people.

 

Author: Dmitry Timofeev psychologist, proEgo platform expert


📚 Recommended literature and images used in the article

For those who want to delve deeper into the topic, the author recommends the following sources on which the article is based:

1.     Mikhail Papush, "Psychotechnique of Inner Freedom".
On the foundation of recognition, attachment, and the scheme of subject formation.

2.     Martin Buber, "I and Thou".
The basic philosophy of dialogue, the distinction between "I-Thou" and "I-It".

3.     René Girard, "I See Satan Fall Like Lightning".
The clearest book on the nature of envy, imitation, and the role of the victim.

4.     René Girard, "The Scapegoat" and "Violence and the Sacred".
Fundamental works on the mechanisms of collective aggression.

5.     Paul Ricœur, "The Course of Recognition".
Philosophical reflection on how we get to know and recognize each other.

6.     Erving Goffman, "The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life".
Microsociology: how our daily gestures and masks are structured.

\n

7.     Alexey Ashkerov, "Social Philosophy" (lecture course).
About society as a daily act of choice.

\n

8.     René Magritte — "The Treachery of Images" (La reproduction interdite), 1937, used in this article.

\n

9.   Emperor Marcus Aurelius performs a sacrifice before the Temple of Jupiter Capitolinus. Roman bas-relief from the Antonine era. Marble, approx. 176–180 CE. Location: Capitoline Museums (Palazzo dei Conservatori), Rome.

Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoОтношенияЖизненные целиИстинное ЯДмитрийТимофеевПризнание
Views: 413

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!