On Emptiness as a Touch to the Sacred Self

Философия жизни
Нинель
Нинель Ерофеева
26 февраля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
On Emptiness as a Touch to the Sacred Self

In the European tradition, emptiness is evil, fullness is good. To achieve good, it is necessary to overcome emptiness and realize fullness, that is, it is necessary to act, to create (A.A. Kokovkina). In the Eastern tradition, emptiness potentially contains all meanings and all possibilities. It is primary and perfect; accordingly, fullness is assessed negatively, as the destruction of perfection.

Unlike static fullness, emptiness implies movement. It is movement itself. For Taoists, emptiness is a kind of void, nothingness at the moment of transition, qualitative change, a process of development. Whole fullness can only rest; it has nowhere and no reason to move. Whereas emptiness continuously self-empties and thereby generates the new.

The French philosopher Henri-Louis Bergson writes in his work "Thought and the Moving":

"The illusory idea of absolute emptiness is, in reality, the idea of universal fullness, arising in a mind that endlessly leaps from part to part, deciding always to consider only the emptiness of its dissatisfaction, and not the fullness of things. The idea of Nothingness is the idea of Everythingness."

Thus, we discover the mutual coexistence of phenomena such as emptiness and fullness.

Disappearing People: Emptiness in the Eyes of the Other

If we apply this perspective to the narcissistic experience, the question arises: when speaking of emptiness, can we assume that a notion of something's presence originated, and subsequently its absence was discovered?

An important stage in a child's development is to be reflected in the gaze of another person (H. Kohut). If we imagine a child's appearance in the eyes of a mother who expects to see something in him, and does not find what she desires. What she sees is emptiness for her. But is it emptiness at all? An excerpt from Louis Aragon's poem "Haunted by Elsa" illustrates this:

In vain your image rushes to meet me

Where I am, he is not, I will not welcome him

My gaze is a wall, and on it you will find

Only a shadow of a dream that you yourself create

My eyes are a mirrored window

And reflections they are not meant to see

In empty pupils, it will find a dwelling

Your blinding absence.

The "Self" (narcissistic) appeared in such a way that it vanished. In the parent's gaze, I am not reflected; or rather, what I truly am, or what truly exists within me, is not reflected. And the absence of this reflection remains within me precisely as an absence, specifically, the absence of myself.

American psychoanalyst Benjamin Kilborne notes in his book «Disappearing Persons: Shame and Appearance»: after several years of analysis, one of his patients does not look at him. He tells her about this, but she calmly replies: «When I don't look at you, I invent you.» That is, if she were to see the real analyst, she would have to see her real self in his eyes — with all her weaknesses and shortcomings.

An infant cannot comprehend the absence of a mother's response, and this is experienced as annihilation anxiety. The child endlessly hopes to correct the situation and «appear» by transforming themselves into a «good» one, perfectly matching parental expectations.

Life in a Glass House

Swiss psychotherapist Alice Miller figuratively articulated the situation of such a child:

«I live in a glass house, into which my mother can look at any time. I can only hide something under the floor, but then I won't be able to see it myself».

Over time, a child, encountering reality, learns to deal with it and lives, reconciling with the imperfection of the world and their vulnerability. But within a narcissistic family, a child does not have such an opportunity. They build their existence around a vital necessity — the thirst to be reflected, constantly striving to be completed in the eyes of another through changing images.

The child has to become «strong», seek support only within themselves, arrange an isolated world where they don't need anyone, create an «Ideal Self». An inflated figure, filled with imaginary qualities, is created. As an adult, a person with narcissistic experience always feels that they can be exposed at any moment, that inside they are a child in need of help. Their authentic Self remains in a rudimentary state, which causes feelings of rootlessness and spiritual emptiness.

The Transformation of Nothing into Something: Therapy through Emptiness

For the transformation of «nothing» into «something» to happen, a retreat is necessary: to free the parent (and with them, the entire world) and oneself from idealizing expectations. Only after approaching one's own emptiness is there a chance that vital forces may be found where previously there was only fear.

Russian philosopher V.V. Bibikhin presents M. Heidegger's thoughts on Nothing and nihilism.

Nothing is a very tangible existential experience, when everything leaves us, the heart constricts in anguish and horror. This is a chance to meet oneself.

Nihilism, however, is the fright from this horror, when we start taking measures against it (alcoholism, reckless behavior, immersion in ideology). Nihilism wants to avoid the experience of pure Nothing, to switch away.

This escape fills the narcissistic experience: the fear of «falling» into the basement of one's own Self and meeting there an unknown, defeated, and humble self.

"The experience of 'nothingness' is difficult to endure without professional therapeutic support. Our task is presence in emptiness. The therapist needs to strengthen their connection with symbols fertilized by spirit, not flesh... That which can help embody nothingness through an image" (Yulia Filatova).

In our laboratory, we began compiling a list of 'warming' works of art. This includes works by S. Kierkegaard ('The Sickness Unto Death') and sculptures by British artist Henry Moore. In his works, the absence of detail (emptiness within the form) evokes not a sense of loss, but an effect of presence, allowing one to look through or even into the form.

The Hours on the Mount of Olives

A beautiful image can be found in Bibikhin's book 'Early Heidegger'. The experience of abandonment transforms into the acceptance of one's cup, becoming a limit from which it becomes possible to push off — through humility, inconsolability, and trust in something greater. Bibikhin quotes Heidegger's student poem:

The hours of my life, the hours on the Mount of Olives:

in the dim glimmer of cowardly hesitation

you often looked at me.

In tears I cried: only not in vain.

My young being, weary from weeping,

only trusted the angel "Grace".

This short poem is about the experience of abandonment in the Garden of Gethsemane, from which one does not flee, which one does not seek, but which one accepts. Heidegger sees not the sublime, but the twilight side of forsakenness, of faint-hearted hesitation, from which he does not break free, nor does he take frantic measures.

Man accepts emptiness, but does not allow it to remain just emptiness. Through him, thanks to his patience, emptiness ceases, and the fullness of waiting begins. Waiting for what man himself cannot arrange. The angel comes or does not come; we do not command it. Grace comes here as it pleases. But home is found precisely here.

Author: Ninel Erofeeva, psychologist, accredited expert of the proEgo platform


References:

  1. Bakhtin M.M. "Author and Hero in Aesthetic Activity"

  2. Bergson A. "Thought and the Moving"

  3. Bibikhin V.V. "Early Heidegger"

  4. Kilborne B. "Disappearing Persons: Shame and Appearance"

  5. Kokovkina A.A. "Axiology of Emptiness in Eastern and European Traditions", 2011

  6. Lacan J. "The Seminars. Book XI. The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis", 2004

  7. Miller A. "The Drama of the Gifted Child and the Search for the True Self", 2001

  8. Ashton P. "On the Edge. The Experience of Emptiness from the Perspective of Depth Psychology"

    *Note: Mentions of I. Mares's seminars and Yu. Filatova's supervisions are integrated into the text as quotes.

Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoИстинное ЯИдентичностьЖизненные целиМышлениеНинельЕрофеева
Views: 397

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!