Review: Charles Darwin's Mirrors
Article narration
Loading…Freedom between an ancient monster and mirrors of fear
For me, the current meaning-making trend is unclear. The path is blurred. We are torn between two poles, both of which seem like a reduction to me: on the one hand, the world as an arena of struggle where the strong prevail (thanks, Charles Darwin), on the other hand, the world as a network of cooperation and mirror neurons (thanks, Joachim Bauer).
The latter is, of course, ethically more elegant, more pleasant. But the essence is the same: they are trying to foist on us an ethics justified by biology. It's like saying: we bent down because we dropped a candy. But we might not bend down. We can. Everything lies in this "can".
Between two monsters
When we speak of ethics, we must remain within its layer. Here, on this thin layer, freedom, responsibility, personality, choice coexist. And all around — forces.
-
On one side – the ancient monster of survival, demanding any price.
-
On the other – a monster born in the brain's biochemistry, pushing us towards the pack, towards approval, towards the warmth of a common body.
And so, this 'I,' small and conscious, stands between these monsters. What freedom can there be here? But it exists. Or does it only seem so to us?
"Is freedom merely the ability to choose which monster to submit to?"
In the absence of certainty, I am simply collecting material. I am observing.
The Victorian Gentleman's Illness
Charles Darwin, the great systematizer of life. He saw how complexity emerged from simplicity, how time shaped forms. It was brilliant. But then he did what a Victorian gentleman with a troubled imagination probably had to do: he declared struggle to be the main driving force.
He endowed nature with his own anxiety. And so it went: survival of the fittest, disappearance of the weak, examination of pedigrees. Germany at the end of the 19th century embraced this with enthusiasm. Ernst Haeckel, August Weismann, Alfred Ploetz — doctors, professors, men of science — spoke of cyanide for defective children, of checking the «quality» of genes before marriage, of how useful it was for society to get rid of the elderly. Thirty years later, all of Germany would think the same way.
And so I ride the Moscow metro. Rush hour. And in moments of misanthropy, when these heated bodies, these faces, these bags press in from all sides, I catch myself thinking: «Maybe they're right? Maybe there are too many of us? Maybe force is needed?»
But it's at this moment that I remember something else. I remember not Darwin's theory, but his home.
The Mirror Room
Memories of one of the family's close acquaintances: Charles sits in an armchair, nervous, exhausted, with a shadow of constant fear on his face. And around the house, in the garden, in the arbors, mirrors are placed. An ingenious system. Sitting in his room, he sees the entire estate. And especially — the two roads by which visitors might approach him.
They might enter. They might catch him off guard. Here it is. This is what cannot be shown directly. This is the Real, which shows through the fabric of theory.
All these preachers of struggle, all these priests of power, shouting about the right of the strong, about purification, about getting rid of the weak — they sit in a room surrounded by mirrors. They are not attacking. They are defending themselves. They are in a panic.
«Their theory is not a description of the world; it is a map of their own terror. It is a gigantic neurosis, expanded to cosmic proportions.»
They are afraid that someone will enter. That someone will prove stronger. That the weak, whom they so desperately want to destroy, will one day rise up and kill them. «Struggle for existence» — is not a law of nature. It is a symptom.
Truth Without Mirrors
And mirrors... Mirrors are an attempt to control the uncontrollable. An attempt to see the Other before they see you. An attempt to make the Real (invasion, death, vulnerability) at least visible, at least reflected.
But the mirror does not protect. It only shows the approach of what you fear most.
The truth is not that the strong defeat the weak. Nor is it that we are all obliged to cooperate. The truth is that we are vulnerable beings, trapped in our own skin, looking into mirrors placed along the roads, and trying to invent a theory that will make this unknown bearable.
Darwin was wrong not about science. Darwin was wrong about courage. He could not bear not knowing. He could not bear openness. He populated the world with monsters to justify his own mirrors.
And perhaps ethics begins precisely where we agree to live without mirrors. Where we recognize that we are neither strong nor weak, neither victors nor cooperators. But simply — looking at the road along which someone is walking. And not knowing who it is.
📚 List of Used and Recommended Literature:
Psychoanalysis and the Structure of Reality:
-
Jacques Lacan. "The Names-of-the-Father" (2006).
Key work introducing the triad "Symbolic — Imaginary — Real". The texts in this collection develop ideas about the unconscious and the nature of the human "Self", providing the theoretical basis for what is called "not directly shown" in the article.
Philosophy of Freedom and the Nature of Fear:
-
S.A. Levitsky. "The Tragedy of Freedom" (2011).
A fundamental work on free will. Of particular interest is the section dedicated to the phenomenology of fear and its connection to time and guilt (pp. 327–352), which echoes the image of 'Me Between Monsters'.
-
Frank Faranda. "The Paradox of Fear: How Our Obsession with Safety Prevents Us from Living" (2024).
A clinical study of how the evolutionary survival mechanism turns into a source of constant anxiety and paradoxically influences our actions and theories.
Philosophy of Biology and Critique of Reductionism:
-
Stephen Webster. "Thinking About Biology" (2003).
A book that prompts reflection on the philosophical and social contexts of biology. It contains important sections on reductionism and the political dimension of Darwinism.
-
V.I. Moiseev, O.N. Moiseeva. "Bioethics. Vol. 1. General Part" (2021).
A textbook with a chapter on holism and reductionism, referencing the thesis on the impossibility of reducing ethics to pure biology.
Eugenics: A History of Ideas:
-
Collective of authors. "The Perfect Human: From Eugenics to Genomics" (2017).
This work traces the evolution of ideas about the 'improvement' of human nature from Francis Galton to the present day.
-
Francis Galton. "Hereditary Genius: An Inquiry into its Laws and Consequences" (1869).
The book that marked the beginning of eugenics as a science. Inspired by Darwin's work, Galton attempted to statistically substantiate the hereditary transmission of qualities.
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
