From Prohibition to Meaning. The Word of the Father
Article narration
Loading…— Is it always possible to find someone to blame?
— I'm not talking about blame, I'm talking about responsibility. And it is not necessarily linked to punishment. I'm talking about the fact that it's often worth looking for a cause and reflecting on it.
Does everything have a cause? Is there always someone to blame? And someone responsible? And if so, do they always deserve punishment? Is it worth pondering this? And who should judge all this? Where is the authority that determines responsibility? Are state institutions sufficient for this, or not?
Look, what a simple sketch, yet how many questions it raises.
The Paternal Function: The First Separation
When we talk about the law, we invariably touch upon the paternal function. It is the Father who establishes the first separation between the child and the mother. He appears in their field and demands attention from the mother of his child. He appears as someone unrelated to gestation, the act of birth, and their close postnatal relationship.
He declares the presence of something outside this absolute harmony; he breaks this pair, whose elements cannot exist without each other. But if this separation is not carried out, the pair will merge in search of absolute pleasure. At the point of complete access to each other.
Don't think I don't hear the voice of indignation — what can this father do that I cannot? Indeed, the father has weakened. He no longer has protectors in the form of religious figures behind him; he is no longer the sole guarantor of the family's survival; he no longer holds an exclusive function. But has he become unnecessary because of this?
Indeed, the paternal function can be performed not only by a man, or even just a human, but nevertheless, it must still be realized. In the life of a child, and even an adult, the Law must appear. Not the law that blindly strikes down, not the one that oppresses, not the one that blindly punishes, hiding behind mythical absolute knowledge — the time of such a Father has indeed passed. But is there a need for another?
The Illusion of Absolute Pleasure
If we look around, in modern society we will notice two tendencies:
- Absence of restrictions — everything is permissible, no one has the right to teach you anymore, be happy right now, deny yourself nothing.
- The presence of absolute pleasure — it's right in front of you, just take it.
Considering these two ideas, it truly becomes easy to believe that becoming happy isn't that difficult. It's enough to allow yourself to possess Everything, and then proceed directly to acquiring it.
At this point, a logical gap arises: how can one possess everything? And it seems any of us can grasp this gap. But the thing is, this «Everything», this absolute pleasure, is skillfully packaged in things that are within arm's reach.
Two clicks, and this absolute happiness is already on its way to the nearest pickup point in the form of a new smartphone model. Along with the emptiness that accompanies it. The thing containing absolute pleasure turned out to be a deception. But no problem, it turns out a new model has been released, and the center of the universe has shifted slightly. Time to click twice again.
It's not worth thinking that the situation changes radically with an increase in the cost of purchases. For some, a smartphone is followed by a car, then a vacation abroad, then a house. And if these purchases were made in search of that very «happiness», disappointment is inevitable. A similar situation is often associated with a change in sexual practices and even partners/spouses.
The Tyranny of the Ideal
The paradox is that this apparent freedom from prohibition instantly turns into a new, far crueler tyranny — the tyranny of the ideal.
A society that rejects the symbolic Father does not abolish the need for law — it merely transforms everyone into a paranoid overseer of themselves and others. The absence of an external limit generates not freedom, but unbearable internal pressure — the necessity to be this ideal, all-possessing Father oneself, which, by definition, is impossible.
But the answer is simple: Absolute pleasure does not exist. It never was, isn't, and never will be, for anyone.
The Gift of Meaning Instead of Guilt
How is this connected to the father and his intervention in the mother's relationship with her children? It is the father who informs the child that they do not have constant access to the mother's body. Because his (the Father's) desire is also connected to this body.
What should the child hear?
- What can be desired and not obtained.
- That desire has a limit.
- That besides a child's desire, there are also the desires of other people.
This is the function of the Father — to frame desire and separate it from enjoyment. At some point, someone must say "No", but do so in a way that doesn't make us give up. We all want to hear a 'no' that is accompanied by evidence that there is another way too.
One can live without striving for the absolute, without a constant pursuit of pleasure. To live desiring what is reasonable, what has a limit, what has meaning.
This is the true legacy of the paternal function — not a burden of guilt, but a gift of meaning. It doesn't say 'don't dare,' it says 'enough.' It points to a limit not to deprive, but to endow things with duration, connection, and history.
What to do?
Repair old things — I tell you. Restore vintage furniture. Value what you or your loved ones have made. Perhaps this is the very symbol of desire, tempered by humanity, and not descending into insatiable devouring or totalitarian prohibition.
After all, to repair — means to choose reparation instead of the eternal search and accumulation of enjoyment: to acknowledge damage, limitation, time — and yet invest in connection with things and people.
What to read on the topic
- Jacques Lacan. Seminars, Book 5: Formations of the Unconscious
- Sigmund Freud. "Totem and Taboo"
- Massimo Recalcati. "The Telemachus Complex: On Parents and Children."
- Jean Baudrillard. "The System of Objects"
- Melanie Klein. "Love, Guilt and Reparation"
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
