Panic Attacks. From Neurophysiology to Psychoanalysis
Article narration
Loading…From hysteria to panic attacks
Today I suggest we talk about panic attacks. I want to say right away that this material is based on the articles of the Italian psychoanalyst and psychiatrist Franco de Masi. In my opinion, he managed to combine the psychoanalytic approach to this problem with a medical perspective very accurately.
So, as is known, psychoanalysis owes its appearance to hysteria. It was the symptoms of this illness that became a stumbling block for all existing treatment methods at that time. The massiveness of hysterical symptoms forced the best minds of the medical and parmedical communities to set themselves the goal of finding a key to this ailment. As we understand, Freud coped best.
It seems that nowadays, panic attacks have confidently taken the place of hysteria.
Illustration "The Shepherd's Dream" by Henry Fuseli
Difficulty of diagnosis and bodily manifestations
What is the complexity of this symptom? It's that it is primarily felt as physical. Because of this, many patients have to undergo a huge number of examinations related to the heart, blood vessels, and brain, only to be left with a rather vague diagnosis — vegetative-vascular dystonia. Although it must be said that many are lucky and fall into the hands of a worthy neurologist or psychotherapist who correctly qualifies what is happening. But due to their medical perspective, although they help alleviate the symptom, they most often cannot ensure a person's complete recovery. This is not determined by the quality of the doctor's work, but by the fact that the ultimate solution to the problem goes beyond their qualification. Why this is so, we will try to understand today.
So, in brief: what are panic attacks? Essentially, it is a sudden and unpredictable onset of an episode of intense anxiety. So intense that it completely suppresses the analyzing part of the psyche. This state is accompanied by strong neurovegetative manifestations such as rapid heartbeat, tachycardia, dizziness, tremor, abdominal cramps, widely radiating or localized pain, hyperhidrosis, and a sensation of suffocation.
Panic attacks primarily and mainly affect the body. And here we can read a quote from the Soviet writer and journalist Vasily Grossman. The quote is taken from his book "Good Evening to You":
"I woke up in the middle of the night and realized I was dying. My heart, it seemed, was beating separately from me, I was breathing evenly, but there was no air in my lungs, as if I was breathing only useless nitrogen. A feeling of pre-death anguish gripped me. It seemed to me that my body was leaving me, abandoning me... my arms, legs, my lungs, my heart were leaving me, my "I" was no longer in them, I didn't feel my fingers from the inside, as I was accustomed to feeling them from the first moment of my birth, but from the outside; I became myself, and the body became itself, separate from me. I felt my pulse, I felt my forehead with my palms in a cold sweat, but me, me, my "I" was almost no longer in these fingers, nor in this pulse beating under the pressure of fingers that refused my "I" shelter; and in the cold palm, and in the cold forehead under the palm, there was less and less of me, with each second we parted more and more. And I, in the dark night's stuffiness, almost already abandoned by my body, slipping, crawling out of me, thought with terrible glass-like clarity about what was happening. I was dying. In the refusal of me by my cold, sweaty chest, my pathetic wet fingers, was my end, my doom, my destruction, my death, my unprecedented annihilation to nothing. In them, in these fingers, in these nails, in these armpits, it turned out, I was. ...And this bodiless world, this bodiless universe, which was my "I," was perishing because my fingers, skull, heart muscle were detaching from me, slipping out of my "I." I was dying, and I didn't immediately notice and feel that my fingers had become mine again, that I was inside them again, that my heart was in me, I in it, that my "I" had returned to my lungs, breathing oxygen."
Psyche or physiology?
It must be said that psychoanalysis, in its desire to explain all spheres and manifestations of a person's psychic life, and not just some separate parts of it, initially paid attention to panic attacks. However, now in psychoanalytic literature, descriptions of this symptom are very rarely found. Psychiatry, pharmacology, and cognitive-behavioral therapy attach much greater importance to it. From the outside, it seems that psychoanalysts avoid this topic, but in reality, the answer lies in the fact that our discipline does not deal with working with individual symptoms. From a psychoanalytic point of view, improving the quality of life is impossible without the comprehensive development of a person's personality.
As usually happens in all significant problems of this kind, the cornerstone becomes the view of what is primary — physiology or psyche. Here, Franco de Masi supports me in my vision and unequivocally postulates: panic attacks originate in a person's psychic life, and only then does an automatic neurobiological reaction trigger the pendulum of anxiety to its maximum amplitude.
Furthermore, it is worth noting that a panic attack, or the first experience of one, becomes a traumatic experience for a person, as they genuinely feel that they are dying. In my opinion, this is a significant factor in the repetition and intensification of subsequent episodes. Fear breeds fear. With each panic attack, the plasticity of our brain ensures the construction of new neuro-vegetative circuits, through which the signal passes with less and less energy expenditure. In other words, with each repetition, less and less provocation is needed for an attack. It is this principle that takes a panic attack beyond the control of consciousness. The person knows they won't die, but they believe they will.
Franco De Masi writes:
"When a person experiences a panic attack, they are certain they are about to die; their body tells them of death or, rather, agony. Psychosomatic symptoms are at the forefront: the psyche registers them and translates them as unmistakable signals of an inevitable and ultimate catastrophe."
Fear of death and early childhood experience
At this point, I would like to add that, in my opinion, the intensity of panic attacks, and indeed their appearance in a patient's history, may be related to how that person relates to death. And, apparently, such an individual does not regard it as the cessation of all anxieties, worries, and painful sensations, but quite the opposite — as an eternal state of maximum psychological and bodily tension. But where does such a perception come from?
In my view, the mystery of this phenomenon is described in the article "Fear of Breakdown" by the American pediatrician and psychoanalyst Donald Woods Winnicott. Based on his ideas, it can be assumed that a person who perceives the end of life in this way has already experienced this state of panic in their infancy. And the point here is not that they encountered poor care (although that would explain a lot), but that at some point they felt themselves disappearing under the influence of internal anxieties that no one was able to contain. It is the repetition of this situation of pseudo-disintegration that plays out in the symptomatology of panic attacks in adulthood. De Masi also supports this argument, relying on Freud:
"Freud grasped the automatic and conditioned nature of panic anxiety, caused by more primitive, automatic, and preverbal mechanisms."
The key words here for me are the reference to the preverbal state — a time when a child's experience cannot be expressed in words. De Masi himself concludes his article by stating that he is confident that the source of panic attacks is a collapse in the human unconscious.
A Neuroscience Perspective: Two Paths of Fear
But what does neuroscience tell us on this topic? Here we will briefly need to cover Joseph LeDoux's theory, on which a significant portion of modern neurologists rely when explaining how a panic attack develops.
LeDoux states that there are two paths of fear, referring to how our brain reacts when confronted with danger.
- The primitive fear circuit — simpler, it activates emergency signals that trigger immediate reactions, such as the well-known fight-or-flight responses. This system reacts to cruder fear signals; for its activation, even a partial match of the situation with a dangerous experience that was previously encountered or imagined is sufficient. In other words, for fear to appear, it is not at all necessary for the fear-inducing picture to be fully formed. One stimulus is enough, for example, a loud sound characteristic of a dangerous object appearing. This system cannot be called precise. Its trump card is speed.
- The second fear circuit has a more complex pathway and passes through the evolutionarily newest parts of the brain. It incorporates analytical functions, meaning it is more precise but slower.
Consequently, in matters of survival, the first circuit takes priority. To understand how this works, you can mentally imagine a dark room or a forest where something unexpectedly falls on you. The first reaction will be fear, which will lead to actions aimed at getting to a safer place. Only then will there be an opportunity to figure out what really happened.
As we can see, the choice of the path by which the signal is transmitted is made without our knowledge. We cannot control it. The choice occurs deep within our psyche — in the unconscious. Panic attacks develop similarly: people confidently tell themselves, "I'm fine, this will pass now," but the attack continues to swing the pendulum. The person does not control it.
Yes, some approaches suggest intentionally intensifying a panic attack, challenging it. Apparently, the basis of this method is the breaking of established neural connections, which we discussed above, but for me, this method is questionable. This is partly because even if habituation to this symptom occurs and it causes less discomfort, the primary problem underlying it remains the same.
Franco De Masi writes:
"For a person experiencing a panic attack, an imagined danger is equivalent to a real one. The fact that a panic reaction may not be related to real danger and is a result of imagination helps us understand the lack of association between real and imagined threats that underlies phobias and panic attacks. The amygdala can perceive imaginary constructs as danger signals.
A person prone to phobia creates a catastrophic scene in their psyche that can become real; this scene is burned into memory, becoming a traumatic core capable of inducing terror. A panic attack, created by imagination but felt by the patient as real, is a genuine traumatic experience, and as such, it is stored in traumatic memory."
As a result, at a certain point, a slight tachycardia or even a cardiac systole caused by a minor change in mood becomes sufficient to trigger a panic attack.
As you can see, a blind spot remains in this entire neurophysiological description. Why does the logistics of anxiety signals in our brain work this way? Who chooses this path and who built this road?
Clinical Case: Franco De Masi's Analysis
This is the perfect place to turn to psychoanalytic theory. We will need a case published by the same Franco De Masi. I do not disclose my personal cases due to confidentiality, but generally, many cases in psychoanalysts' practice are repetitive. Therefore, I prefer to use materials from senior colleagues, as there are plenty of them.
"A twenty-five-year-old female patient began analysis with four sessions a week due to recurring panic attacks and hypochondriac episodes that constantly led her to doctors and the emergency room.
In childhood and adolescence, she grew up intelligent and brave, never showing weakness in situations that are usually difficult for a child: she visited doctors without fear and could tolerate physical pain. On the threshold of early adulthood, this protective shell began to fail: she now feared everything, and her imagination constantly created dangers and illnesses, including all sorts of cancers.
In her first dream in analysis, the patient saw herself as a tourist guide who was telling a group of people about the city's sights. In the dream, she understood that she knew neither the city nor its sights.
Evidently, she was showing the analyst how her falsified self accompanied her as she grew up, misleading herself and others into the illusory belief that she knew everything, when in reality, she was probably very poorly equipped to cope with life."
Panic attacks appeared in this patient after two events—the death of her father and the breakup of a romantic relationship. Generally, panic attacks are often triggered by some life crisis, including a mid-life crisis. Here, it is worth recalling the four basic fears: fear of death, fear of bodily and mental harm, fear of losing a loved object, and fear of losing the object's love. My experience shows that one of these four fears is somehow present in the trigger event that caused panic attacks. But why do some people's psyches cope with this more easily than others'? Let's continue to investigate.
Identification and External Supports
De Masi writes about his patient that her excessive self-confidence was linked to the imagined strength of her personality, which was organized around an idealized father. The girl incorporated his behavior model into her psyche. In other words, much of how she acted in various life situations was determined not by her identity, but by the figure of her strong father. At some point in her life, feeling a deficit in her own competence and pressure from her father, the girl, without digesting it, absorbed the image of a strong and decisive man. Now she could not help but be strong and decisive, and her father constantly reinforced this picture of omnipotence.
Describing this patient, De Masi speaks of a need common to many people experiencing panic attacks—the need to occupy a place in the inner world of others and to appear perfect there.
Yes, people like our patient possess courage. But this courage is often built not on the basis of their real qualities, but on external supports—be it someone's strong figure behind them or some material resource that allows them to idealize themselves. This support or resource initially begins to perform a protective function in the person's psyche. But often, this function changes to an aggressive and persecuting one, which begins to demand success rather than protect against failures. What exacerbates the situation is that the internal anxieties of such children receive no attention from outside. They are pushed into the background, ignored year after year.
One might get the false impression that such a development of psychic reality and, consequently, symptomatology, is relevant only for children growing up in affluent families. But this is not the case. The main factor here is how much, on an unconscious level within the family system, a child is stimulated to develop a constant desire to demonstrate success. In other words, the weak, help-seeking, and anxiety-ridden part of the child is expelled from the psyches of both parents. And to return, the child must perform a feat: achieve certain grades, win competitions, master specific skills.
Some children succeed in this. Year after year, they raise their own bar, achieving new and new results. But this is only a small percentage of people who are also forced to sacrifice something else, yet still important. The other, larger group of children cannot meet such external and internal challenges. They feel abandoned by their mothers and fathers. Living in constant tension between their capabilities and expectations (both external and internal), they develop a “second muscular skin.”
This term was proposed by Esther Bick. She meant by it a defense mechanism in which the lack of an internal psychic container for one's experiences stimulates the formation of pseudo-independence through physical and mental tension. Catch the moment: not tension to achieve something, but tension to feel safe — to bind internal anxiety. Because if anxiety is not bound to anything, it becomes nameless dread.
As you can see, the entire range of colors in this case revolves around a person's own identity and authenticity. A psyche built on illusions, on external supports, is doomed to collapse, which will cause unspeakable dread. Because in the conditions of losing these external supports, essentially, the entire personality of such a person collapses. And this is precisely what can, depending on the case, be felt as psychic death, triggering the symptoms of panic attacks.
Therapy: Levels of Intervention
This allows us to understand that therapy for panic states cannot be separated from a person's personality deficits. This assertion is also supported by the fact that panic attacks are preceded by a prolonged anxious state, which may well have continued from an early age, leading to a slowing down of emotional development. This, in turn, affects relationships and professional growth, where communication gains increasingly significant weight.
It should also be noted that the collapse of narcissistic defenses can also provoke panic attacks. With age or due to the realization of one's own limitations, the myth of hyper-efficiency, beauty, and success crumbles. This, in turn, confronts the person with the fact of the importance of object relations, and not just their narcissistic adequacy. At this point, we can observe that we ourselves form the foundation for panic attacks, albeit under the influence of the environment that determines our development. Nevertheless, precisely the part of the psyche responsible for cultivating muscular skin or developing narcissistic structures is also responsible for the collapse of these illusory castles.
We can confidently state that panic attacks are evidence of a catastrophic crisis in a person's inner world and their defenses. And to get through this period, first and foremost, of course, one should resort to prescription-based medication, and secondly — to address their psyche.
De Masi identifies two needs that must be satisfied in therapy for panic states. The first is to understand and learn to control one's anxieties; the second is to form a stable, viable self in place of the self-idealized image.
Conclusion
In conclusion, I want to share Franco de Masi's opinion regarding the effectiveness of different approaches to working with panic attacks.
«A panic attack can also be hierarchically represented at three levels. The lowest, controlled by the amygdala, governs autonomic and somatic reactions. The middle level, the level of traumatic memory, builds associations, visual images, and images in memory that arise in catastrophic imagination. The upper level concerns personality structure, childhood experience, and psychic defenses, i.e., a complex dynamic configuration that not only generates the symptom but also determines the patient's entire inner and relational world.
Therapeutic approaches vary depending on the level at which they operate. At the lowest level, psychotropic medications aim to reduce the strength of neurovegetative reactions triggered by the limbic system, as well as to combat the underlying depressive state. Cognitive therapy, focused on the middle level, seeks to correct the distorted perception of fear using strategies that help break associative links and gradual exposure to the terrifying stimulus. Both approaches aim to free the patient from panic symptoms.
"Psychoanalytic therapy operates at a structural-dynamic level, not just a symptomatic one. The ultimate overcoming of a crisis is possible only due to the specifics of the analytical process and the emotional growth of the analysand."

Sources and Literature:
- Franco De Masi (Franco De Masi). Works on the psychoanalytic study of panic attacks and trauma.
- Donald W. Winnicott. Article "Fear of Breakdown".
- Joseph LeDoux (Joseph LeDoux). Research on the neurobiology of fear and anxiety ("The Emotional Brain", "The Anxious Brain").
- Esther Bick (Esther Bick). Article "The Experience of the Skin in Early Object-Relations" (1968) — the concept of the "second skin".
- Vasily Grossman. "Good to You!" (Collection of travel essays/novel).
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
