Why a parent cannot be friends with their child
Article narration
Loading…1. Different "Weight Categories"
Friendship implies a relationship between equals: equals in status, age, and the ability to be an authority for each other. A friend is first and foremost a partner, support, and a source of strength. This is someone who will pick you up, give advice, and to whom you are not bound by kinship.
If for you, an adult, a teenage child becomes such a partner, this raises a question for you: how did it happen that you rely on a child as an equal? Perhaps it's time to re-evaluate your views on parent-child relationships and on yourself in the context of the valuable aspects of life. Relationships where a parent "friends" with a child are unbalanced: weakness, vulnerability, and the right to not know should rightfully belong to the younger, and strength and invulnerability to the adult.
2. Role Reversal and Loss of Support
There are kinship ties between a mother and child that have a certain nuance. A mother is someone who is responsible for the child, is an authority figure, and shows by example how to live. When a mother becomes just a "friend" to her child, talks about her difficulties, complains about her husband or boss, and seriously consults with a teenager, this is detrimental to the child.
A teenager cannot bear responsibility for an adult; they do not yet have their own formed values. In psychology, this destructive process is called parentification — when a child functionally or emotionally becomes a parent to their own mother. A child who becomes a friend to a parent pays for this with their childhood. They are forced to contain (accommodate and process) the adult's emotions, while their own feelings remain unnoticed.
British psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott described this mechanism in detail through the loss of "holding" — a safe container. An adult must be strong enough to tolerate a child's emotions. In friendship, however, the child subconsciously fears upsetting their adult "friend," begins to serve their feelings, and forms a "False Self." They become accustomed to playing a role, to "seeming" rather than "being," because expressing their true self (weak, angry, rebellious) becomes unsafe — the "friend" might not tolerate it, get offended, and withdraw love. As a result, the teenager stops understanding themselves.
3. The Trap of Hidden Control and Double Messages
Often, behind a mother's "friendship" lies the desire to keep the child under complete control: by getting close, to extract secrets, to know everything about their plans and intimate circle. This is a trap of double messages, brilliantly described by the classic of family psychotherapy Virginia Satir.
The parent says: "We're friends, tell me everything." The child trusts. But as soon as sincerely shared secrets touch upon parental anxiety, they turn against the teenager in the form of lectures and prohibitions. This leaves an indelible mark on the psyche. The child feels manipulated and does not learn honest relationships. In such an alliance, the mother does not openly legalize her power but uses parental authority secretly, striking where the child least expects it.
It is much more honest to be a strict parent, to show uncompromisingness where rules are broken. If control is important to you — openly acknowledge this right! Yes, this will provoke the child's dissatisfaction and it will be impossible to maintain smooth relations. But it is precisely this that will provide the teenager with a clear position, from which they can begin to build their own system of values by opposing it. In cunning "friendship," the mother becomes unpredictable: sometimes she communicates as an equal, sometimes she displays despotism. Trust is permanently lost.
4. Blurred Boundaries and Intergenerational Coalitions
In such a “friendship,” children lose their boundaries: they begin to feel that all paths are open and there are no social restrictions. But the problem is even deeper.
The creator of structural family therapy Salvador Minuchin emphasized that in a healthy family, the boundaries between the parents' and children's levels should be clear. When a mother shares adult problems with her daughter, a pathological “role confusion” occurs.
This is also confirmed by Anna Varga (founder of the Russian school of systemic family psychotherapy). She directly states: when a mother and daughter become “friends,” a hidden intergenerational coalition most often arises. The mother is friends with the daughter against the father (or vice versa). The child is mercilessly drawn into adult conflicts. This is psychological abuse of the child, as they lose the status of being “younger” and protected. In a healthy family, boundaries should be impenetrable to “adult” problems.
5. Gestalt approach: emptiness instead of a foundation for separation
In these relationships, the parent, first and foremost, is not honest with themselves. You are not showing the child an example of healthy interaction with the world.
Gestalt therapists (in particular, the outstanding child psychologist Violet Oaklander) write extensively about contact boundaries. For a teenager to successfully individuate (separate and become an independent personality), it is vitally important for them to push off from the parent. The child relies on the resistance of the environment: on your rules, prohibitions, your firm parental stance.
If you are a soft, understanding “friend” who agrees with every whim, the teenager has nothing to push off from. They fall into emptiness. This is why children of such “advanced” parents often go to extremes (thrills, addictions, self-destruction) — they desperately seek any rigid boundaries of reality and try to make you finally become an Adult.
6. The secret support: why children need an adult
As Lyudmila Petranovskaya writes in her “Secret Support”: “It is important to remain a parent for the child, and a parent is someone who cares.” For a child to develop calmly and explore this complex world, their “rear” must be stable, monumental, and predictable.
If a parent is a “friend,” they are no longer the dominant, caring figure. The position of equality frightens children at a deep biological level. The child loses their support and is forced to become an adult prematurely.
In all these conclusions, I am not unsubstantiated. Science is unanimous: growing up in such an insidious friendship, a child is deprived of the most valuable experience — a relationship with an Adult who can admit their mistakes without fear of losing face, and who can withstand a child's anger without crumbling.
True authority is not gained by force or bought by familiarity; it is born in a space of safety. This cannot be called friendship, and it is infinitely far from healthy parent-child relationships.
Illustration for the article
Created by AI-proEgo based on the painting Pablo Picasso, “Girl on a Ball” (1905, Rose Period).
Why this painting was chosen:
This painting is an ideal visual metaphor for a healthy family system. The canvas contrasts two figures: a powerful, unwavering athlete sitting heavily on a cube, and a fragile girl balancing on a movable, unstable sphere.
In healthy relationships, the parent is the athlete on the cube. They embody gravity, stability, and a reliable back-up. The adult is predictable and firmly grounded. And the child is the girl on the sphere. The teenager seeks balance, makes mistakes, takes risks; their psyche is unstable. And the girl can allow herself this risk of development only because a huge, motionless adult sits nearby, who will prevent her from falling at any second.
When you decide to become a "friend" to your child, you push the athlete off the cube. You demand that the fragile child's psyche become your support, while you yourself climb onto the unstable sphere of your fears. The child cannot bear the weight of an adult — and the system crashes with a bang. Leave children their lightness and the right to be younger, and become an unwavering support for them yourselves.
Bibliography / Sources:
1. Winnicott D. W. Little Children and Their Mothers. — M.: Klass, 1998.
2. Minuchin S., Fishman Ch. Techniques of Family Therapy. — M.: Klass, 1998.
3. Satir V. You and Your Family. A Guide to Personal Growth. — M.: EKSMO-Press, 2000.
4. Varga A. Ya. Systemic Family Psychotherapy. A Short Lecture Course. — St. Petersburg: Rech, 2001.
5. Oklender V. Windows to the Child's World. A Guide to Child Psychotherapy. — Moscow: Klass, 1997.
6. Petranovskaya L. V. Secret Support: Attachment in a Child's Life. — Moscow: AST, 2015.
7. Neufeld G., Maté G. Hold On to Your Kids. — Moscow: Resurs, 2012.
8. Bowlby J. Attachment. — Moscow: Gardariki, 2003.
9. Bowen M. Murray Bowen's Family Systems Theory. — Moscow: Kogito-Tsentr, 2005.
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
