About AI and psychologists: why we are not equal.
Article narration
Loading…From the Editors. Can artificial intelligence replace a psychologist? If we are looking for a "pill" for emotional pain or a tool for behavior correction, the answer is yes. But psychotherapy is more than just symptom relief. In her column, Ninel Yerofeyeva reflects on why real change is impossible without risk, instability, and the living presence of the Other, and where the line lies between functional use and genuine Encounter.
The Psychologist as Function and "Pill"
I wrote my answer to the question of why an AI bot cannot replace a psychologist, but I didn't stop thinking about it. And this topic reappeared before me, but from a different angle. I was interested in what position I could take to view these phenomena — the psychologist and artificial intelligence — as equals?
What I missed in my previous answer, and what is perhaps the essence — is the very approach to the phenomenon. How can they become the same for me, and thus indifferent, and thus impersonal?
Probably from the position where I view the phenomenon of "psychologist" (let's put it in quotes, as the word is used here in a narrow context) as a tool. As a thing. As a pill. A talking gadget that will give me a solution, listen, or say something I expect. Answer my request.
In search of such a specialist, I first look at "quality." Imported? Domestic? (Oh right, Chinese). I don't care about their life story, their gaze, their manner of speaking — all that is secondary. It influences, but it's not what I'm looking at. I'm looking at the result.
Headache gone — the pill helped.
- “You know, my panic attacks have returned. It was so good at first, but now it’s back.”
- Or often: “Well, he’s not listening to me again, and he didn’t do his homework yesterday.”
You're not helping, in other words. And from this perspective, where I view the specialist as a pill, I can easily change it. Or allow that if it's not helping (or, conversely, if things have gotten easier) — why do I need it? And at some point, decide to stop therapy. To decide it myself. Like taking a pill and stopping.
The Illusion of Relationships with AI
From this perspective, AI is a similar phenomenon for a person as the "psychologist-function." One can ask it — or not. One can take it seriously, listen to it, or not. It's not that I seriously now live with the awareness that there is this third person in my life — a psychologist. Not my mother, not myself, not God, but a psychologist — a human being, but of a special kind. Another person.
For something to truly work and for the "pill" not just to relieve symptoms, a special connection is needed. And certainly, it is not one-sided, like the connection of an owner with an object, like utilization, like manipulating an object to achieve a goal.
AI becomes such a tool. But psychotherapy is impossible with it.
The Right to Instability: A Step Towards Change
For therapy to take place, both the therapist (I'll use this word as it resonates more with me) and the client must find themselves in a place of instability and surrender of power, both of them.
The therapist allows themselves to be influenced by the client with their situation and their history, and in turn, influences the client. And only there will their influence reach its goal, where there is the client's readiness to absorb. Where there is their attention(from the word 'vnyat' - to heed, to absorb). Where there is a readiness for something new to penetrate and touch, to dislodge, to sway.
This is similar to how physical instability is necessary for the next step: we shift our weight, lift one leg, and for a moment find ourselves suspended in a very precarious position. And in us, there is trust in the earth at that moment, as something greater that holds and accepts me.
This instability is precisely ensured by the fact that we no longer know, no longer control this ground; we are suspended, we have no power to decide. But this is precisely what ensures our next step — opening ourselves to influence. Opening through trust and entrusting ourselves for a moment to the Other. And through this courage, the possibility of change emerges.
Summary
Perhaps enough has now been said to be able to differentiate:
- If I need a tool, not change — an AI chat will suit me perfectly.
- If I am looking for change and am willing to tolerate the Other next to me — I can try therapy.
Author: Ninel Erofeeva, psychologist, accredited expert of the proEgo platform
Recommended Literature and Context (from the editors)
The topic raised by the author echoes ideas from existential psychology and psychoanalysis about object relations and intersubjectivity. For those who want to delve deeper into the question of «Meeting» and the distinction between instrumental and authentic communication, we recommend:
- Martin Buber, «I and Thou». A philosophical foundation on the distinction between «I-It» relationships (where the other is an object/tool, like AI) and «I-Thou» (where an authentic Meeting is possible).
- Donald W. Winnicott, «The Use of an Object and Relating through Identifications». On how important it is for the psyche not just to use an object, but to experience its survival and acknowledge its external reality.
- Irvin Yalom, «The Gift of Therapy». On the healing power of «here and now» therapeutic relationships, which cannot be replicated with an algorithm.
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
