Labor productivity and business efficiency in Russia. Depth psychology of problems

Бизнес
Дана
Дана Янсон
20 апреля 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Labor productivity and business efficiency in Russia. Depth psychology of problems

The Economic Symptom as a Manifestation of the Collective Unconscious

The Russian business community in 2026 found itself facing a historical Rubicon. We witnessed a unique moment when macroeconomic indicators, state strategy, and the deep psychology of the masses converged at one point, revealing a systemic national-scale problem — critically low labor productivity.

For a long time, this phenomenon was viewed exclusively within a purely economic and technocratic discourse: as a consequence of fixed asset depreciation, software shortages, or logistics imperfections. However, today, when extensive development paths (the strategy of throwing money and personnel at problems) are finally exhausted, it becomes obvious: low productivity is not only an economic but also an unconscious defense mechanism of society.

In this article, we will conduct a deep analytical study of the anatomy of this labor paralysis, trace the historical roots of authoritarian management, and explain why professional individual psychotherapy, carried out beyond the company's boundaries, is today the only tool capable of returning to business not just efficiency, but also the ability to create world-class products.

Macroeconomic Context: When Stagnation Becomes a Threat to GDP

The modern rhetoric of the state apparatus confirms the seriousness of the diagnosis. The head of the Central Bank, Elvira Nabiullina, directly states: the development of the Russian economy today is hindered not by the key rate, but by personnel shortages and low labor productivity. This is a conceptual acknowledgment that the old unspoken psychological contract between business and the state (we pay little, you work little) no longer ensures the stability of the system.

Minister of Economic Development Maxim Reshetnikov introduces the term «unproductive employment», referring to millions of people who are physically present at their workplaces but do not create added value. From a psychological perspective, we are dealing with a manifestation of presenteeism — physical presence with total emotional and cognitive absence. The authorities state: personnel shortage is a new reality. But as a psychoanalyst, I see in this not only a demographic pit but also a mass exodus of the subject from labor relations. People have massively stopped investing their creative energy in work, retreating into deep psychological defense.

Genesis of the Problem: Authoritarian Vertical and the Burden of Virtual Crowns

The roots of the current paralysis lie in a historically established management model, which can be psychoanalytically characterized as a denial of subjectivity. For decades, Russian management was built on a rigid authoritarian vertical. In such a system, the Decision-Making Person (DMP) often unconsciously took the position of an omnipotent and punishing parent.

This dynamic was actively supported by a culture of nepotism, where key positions were filled not based on strict professional criteria, but on the principle of personal devotion and loyalty. Business success was measured exclusively by external, narcissistic attributes of grandeur — headquarters in Moscow City and bloated staff sizes, who were expected to applaud a leader with a virtual crown on their head.

From the perspective of object relations theory, such an environment inevitably fosters a stable infantile pattern in employees. If a leader autocratically seizes all power, all initiative, and the exclusive right to make mistakes, the employee naturally and inevitably regresses to the position of a dependent child. They readily forgo responsibility, creativity, and initiative in exchange for illusory, passive security. Today, when the era of expensive money and total automation demands unprecedented mobility, autonomy, and the work of distributed teams, this cumbersome authoritarian structure is crumbling. However, management, accustomed to manual control for decades, continues to desperately cling to micro-management, not understanding that it is precisely this suffocating control that blocks productivity.

Job Hugging, the «Freeze» reaction, and the influence of hidden personal traumas

We are observing a total epidemic of the phenomenon of Job Hugging (clinging to work). In the harsh conditions of recent years, burdened by loans, mortgages, and paralyzing fear of macroeconomic uncertainty, Russian employees are massively falling into a state of psychological stupor. In the classic biological triad of reactions to threat «fight, flight, freeze», personnel unconsciously chose to freeze. The strategy of fighting for innovation and arguing with management is perceived as too dangerous an action. The strategy of seeking a new, better job is paralyzed by the fear of losing stable income and the risk of cash flow gaps. Freezing becomes the only available strategy for psychological survival.

Job Hugging is not loyalty to the employer's brand. It is the desperate grip of a frightened person on a life raft. The employee masterfully imitates activity, doesn't take sick leave, and isn't late, but at the same time, they are almost completely disengaged from the real, creative work process. Their psychic energy is not directed at the task; it is entirely spent on maintaining a socially approved mask and suppressing immense internal anxiety.

But we must go deeper. Productivity is destroyed not only by the general background of uncertainty or mortgages. Employees bring the full spectrum of their personal, deeply intimate pain, which directly blocks their professional function, into the psychotherapist's online office. Divorce, illness of a close relative, existential midlife crisis, fear of loneliness, panic disorders, depressive disorders, and deep childhood traumas — all this does not remain at the office doorstep. A person experiencing a marital breakdown or struggling with depression is unable to generate brilliant marketing strategies or optimize their work processes. Their inner world is engulfed in flames, and the workplace becomes merely a backdrop where they play out their personal tragedies. It is impossible to demand high added value from an employee if their internal supports are compromised and all their energy is spent servicing personal trauma.

The organization as a living organism: office romances, mobbing, and group dynamics

To understand the true causes of low efficiency, it is necessary to abandon a mechanistic view of business. An organization is not a set of gears in a mechanism; it is a complex, pulsating living organism, permeated by a web of unconscious human connections. Within any team, powerful processes are continuously unfolding: strong friendships and toxic enmities emerge, office romances ignite, coalitions form, bullying (mobbing) and competition for the attention of a symbolic parent-leader thrive.

Any work group regresses in moments of stress. The team stops working and unconsciously begins to serve one of several fantasies: either it seeks a savior (dependence), or it unites against an imagined enemy, or it breaks into pairs, expecting that some office romance or alliance of two leaders will miraculously save the company. In these conditions, classic group team-building is absolutely useless — it only works with the superficial, facade level of interaction and often only strengthens hidden paranoia.

This is where corporate psychotherapy comes in, including its group format (Balint groups, dynamic groups). Unlike a business coach, a group psychotherapist works with the shadow side of the team. They help the group become a cohesive team, legitimize suppressed aggression, healthily process conflicts, unpack projections, and break free from destructive games, returning the group's energy back to its work task.

Analytical Setting: Why a Psychotherapist Must Be Outside the System

Here we approach a crucial scientific aspect that explains the concept of the proEgo platform. Why psychotherapy should be provided by an independent, external provider. Why an in-house psychologist often proves ineffective.

The answer lies in the strict requirements of the psychotherapeutic setting. An in-house psychologist is inevitably entangled in the same system of power and financial coordinates as their employee-clients. They receive their salary from the same management, which in the collective's unconscious perception makes them either a brother/sister to compete with, or an agent of oversight reporting team weaknesses to management. In such conditions, it's impossible to create a space of true trust and safety.

An external platform, such as proEgo, acts as a guarantor of independence. A platform psychotherapist is not involved in company intrigues, does not depend on the CEO's mood, and guarantees absolute confidentiality. Only by being outside the pathogenic system can a specialist become that objective mirror and safe container that allows an employee to open up and work through their deepest fears without fear of corporate repercussions.

From Masking Symptoms to World-Class Products

Traditionally, business attempts to treat managerial paralysis with business coaching or personal growth trainings. However, a fundamental methodological error lies here. Coaching works exclusively with the conscious part of the personality, directly offering new tools and skills. But if the foundation of the personality is in a state of deep conflict or unprocessed trauma, coaching becomes an attempt to beautifully repaint the walls of a burning building.

A business coach merely masks symptoms. They provide sales scripts, strict time management, and motivational slogans, which create a short-term, hysterical surge of activity by mobilizing the last reserves of willpower. But willpower — a finite and rapidly depleting resource. As soon as the training ends, an even deeper, more destructive burnout inevitably follows.

A psychotherapist, however, works with the root cause. They don't teach a person to work better; they work with fears, projections, and personal pain that make intellectual work impossible. Psychotherapy — is not about learning new hard skills; it's about restoring a person's very capacity for creative activity.

This is where the secret to global competitiveness lies. When psychic energy is freed from the need to service internal conflicts, fears, and suppressed aggression, it is sublimated into creativity. Psychologically healthy, mature teams effectively create products and services that do not need government protection, aggressive marketing, or manipulative tricks to sell in any market.

Mechanisms of Psychotherapy's Impact on Productivity

Let's break down step-by-step how working with an employee's personality directly translates into concrete metrics of a company's economic efficiency.

1. Affective Regulation and Restoration of Cognitive Resources

In a state of chronic anxiety and stress (regardless of whether caused by a mortgage, fear of dismissal, or a difficult divorce), a person's amygdala — the threat recognition center — is constantly active. Biologically, this means an immediate suppression of the prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for long-term planning, logic, and complex decision-making. By helping the client to healthily contain anxiety and alleviate panic attacks, the therapist physiologically shifts the brain from survival mode to high-level functioning mode. Only after stabilizing the emotional state does the employee regain the ability to maintain focus and analyze complex data sets. This is the biological foundation of all productivity.

2. Dismantling Learned Helplessness and Restoring Agency

Learned helplessness is a natural consequence of prolonged exposure to a system where initiative was punished. In the safe, accepting space of the therapeutic alliance, the client rediscovers their ability to influence reality. By working through deep traumas, an individual begins to clearly recognize their professional boundaries and their worth. This leads them to stop passively waiting for instructions for every step and to start independently taking responsibility for their work area. They become a full-fledged agent of activity, not a convenient tool in someone else's hands.

3. Separating the Task from the Ego and the Right to Make Mistakes

For a narcissistically vulnerable employee, any error in a report or work process — is not just a setback, but a fatal confirmation of their complete inner worthlessness. The terror of this experience compels people to skillfully hide problems until the very last moment of the deadline, causing enormous losses to the business. We help the client build strong internal support, where their basic self-esteem is separated from operational work results. The healthy construct «My solution didn't work» stops meaning «I am worthless.» When the fear of annihilation upon making a mistake disappears, the employee becomes genuinely capable of bold experimentation and breakthrough innovations.

4. Breaking Down Projections and Rejecting Passive Aggression

Under stress, employees are prone to massively project the powerful figure of a tyrannical parent onto their leader. In response, an infantile childish defense inevitably activates: external, ostentatious obedience, behind which hides powerful sabotage (a go-slow strike). By thoroughly working through this transference, the employee begins to see the leader not as an omnipotent punisher, but simply as a living person vested with specific functions. Communication becomes utterly transparent: an adult can openly and argumentatively state that a task is unfeasible within the given timeframe, instead of nodding obediently and then failing the deadline.

Psychotherapy as a Strategic Investment. A View for Decision-Makers (DMs)

Low company productivity — is often the long shadow of its leader's unresolved personal limitations. Widespread management paralysis is most often caused by a leader's exaggerated need for total micro-control. And behind this compulsive control always lies a panicked fear of uncertainty and mistrust of the world. In personal psychotherapy, the leader learns to contain their immense anxiety, ceasing to unleash it on subordinates in the form of toxic micromanagement and contradictory directives.

A leader's recognition of the vital necessity of corporate psychotherapy, both for their employees and for themselves — is an act of managerial maturity and courage. It is a voluntary renunciation of the infantile illusion of a virtual crown in favor of objective reality. It is a deep understanding that a truly effective enterprise — is not a certain number of faceless cogs in a machine, but a voluntary union of psychologically healthy, mature individuals.

Conclusion. Honesty as the Foundation of Global Efficiency

We have reached a historical point where radical honesty with ourselves becomes the most commercially advantageous strategy. Old, outdated methods of manipulation, directive coercion, and cheap motivational boosts no longer work in an economy of expensive money, staffing shortages, and global transparency.

Low labor productivity in Russia is not just a line in economic reports. It is a collective cry for help from the human psyche, exhausted by years of authoritarianism, uncertainty, and learned helplessness. Systemic corporate psychotherapy is not a trendy social package or a pleasant benefit. It is, to date, the only scientifically substantiated technology capable of shifting an individual from a regressive strategy of freezing to a progressive strategy of creation.

Psychotherapy has no magic. It doesn't make people geniuses. It makes them healthy and mature. And in conditions of a systemic macroeconomic crisis, it is precisely the mature, conscious, and agentic human psyche that constitutes that insurmountable competitive advantage. An advantage that not only guarantees a business's survival but also allows it to create great products that change the global market.

Dana Yanson

psychoanalyst, PhD in Psychology,
founder of the proEgo online professional psychotherapy platform

List of Recommended Literature and Sources:

1.    Bion, W. R. Experiences in Groups and Other Papers. A work on the analysis of unconscious group dynamics and the phenomenon of basic assumptions in work collectives.

2.    Kernberg, O. F. Ideology, Conflict, and Leadership in Groups and Organizations. An exploration of leadership and corporate governance pathologies from a psychoanalytic perspective.

3.    Winnicott, D. W. Playing and Reality. The foundations of the transitional space concept, explaining the necessity of a safe, independent setting for the development of agency.

4.    Kets de Vries, M. The Leadership Mystique: A User's Manual for the Human Enterprise. An analysis of how the shadow sides of a leader's personality are projected onto corporate culture and destroy company productivity.

5.    Freud, S. Group Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego. The basic theory of connections within any collective and the role of the leader.

6.    Macroeconomic statistics data and public speeches by heads of the economic block of the Russian Federation (Central Bank of the Russian Federation, Ministry of Economic Development, 2025-2026) on overcoming the labor market crisis and increasing productivity.

 

Views: 419

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!