"Child" and "Adult": Two Poles of the Mental World
Article narration
Loading…When a psychological term becomes popular and takes root in everyday language, its original deep meaning is often lost. The term becomes flat, almost devoid of logic.
The same situation happened with the phrase: "There's a child living in every adult".
I think everyone has heard this. It usually implies a certain infantile sensitivity, vulnerability, or a demand for pleasure. But what does it actually mean from the perspective of our psyche's architecture? Let's figure it out.
Oceanic Feeling: Where the "Inner Child" Comes From
Since we are talking about describing the inner world, we are dealing with a psychic structure. If there is a child part, there must also be an adult part. Freud said, "The child is the father of the adult." Melanie Klein deepened this thought: "The infant is the father of the adult."
What constitutes the world of an infant? It is an organized "inner world," but it is preverbal. It is filled not with symbols, but with body rhythms, affects, and relationships with the mother.
In this world, there are no boundaries, no separation into "I" and "not-I." It is something oceanic — infinite, homogeneous, and all-encompassing. If an adult imagines themselves in such a state, they will feel either absolute tranquility (when the ocean is calm) or the absolute horror of helplessness (when the ocean storms).
Gradually, outlines begin to emerge in this "soup." The Mother performs this function (as a living instrument). She is the one who creates the child's thinking, imbuing with meaning what happens to their body. As Donald Winnicott said: "There is no such thing as a baby. There is only a mother-infant pair.".
Asymmetry and Madness: Two Modes of Brain Function
Over time, the child masters logic. But if we talk to a four-year-old, we will find a lot of mystical and strange equivalences in their thinking.

Chilean psychoanalyst Ignacio Matte-Blanco developed a model explaining this fundamental human contradictoriness. He hypothesized that two information processing modes operate within us:
1. Asymmetrical Logic (Classical). Here 1 is not equal to 2. Here there is time, boundaries, and differences. This is the logic of an adult.
2. Symmetrical Logic (Unconscious). Here, the principles of infinity apply. In this mode, the part is equal to the whole. Here there is no time and no "not".
An infant lives in symmetrical logic. For them, any discomfort is infinite because there is no concept of time ("this will pass soon").
What does this knowledge give us? We begin to understand the nature of irrational breakdowns.
Under certain conditions, symmetrical logic (where everything is equal to everything) begins to prevail over classical logic.
Real-life example:
A man comes home after a difficult day where his boss constantly interfered in his affairs. At home, he lashes out at his wife over an innocent question.
Why? It's not just a matter of "nerves." Under conditions of overload, his psyche switched to a symmetrical mode. His wife's question was perceived as an intrusion. And in unconscious logic, "boss's intrusion" = "wife's intrusion." These figures merged for a time.
Hanna Segal called this "symbolic equation". In stress, sleep, or affect, we confuse fantasy with reality, and one object with another.
Adult Loneliness and the "Zone of the Undifferentiated"
Why doesn't this "confusion" disappear with age?
A child hopes that an adult will understand their logic. But we often lack the strength for it. This abyss in understanding leads to the fact that even a person with a good childhood retains a part of their experience that is inaccessible to symbolization (comprehension).
The primordial ocean of the psyche is filled with continents of logic, but a vast territory is still occupied by the "undifferentiated."
These two principles – symmetric (childlike, psychotic) and asymmetric (adult, logical) – live in us forever. And thank goodness.
Vitality vs. Order: Why We Need "Madness"

Do we need to strive to completely eradicate this "childlike," illogical thinking?
Psychoanalyst Giuseppe Civitarese, referencing Wilfred Bion's ideas on group dynamics, offers an interesting answer.
Bion noted that in any group (even a working one), unconscious, irrational modes ("basic assumptions") are periodically activated. If they take over, productivity drops to zero.
BUT: If these irrational surges are completely absent from a group, it loses its vitality — the feeling of life. The group becomes sterile and dead.
The same thing happens with an individual's psyche.
Classical logic makes our lives safe and productive. But without the symmetric ("mad," childlike) part, the following are impossible:
- Emotional relationships.
- Literature, music, and art.
- Scientific breakthroughs (which require moving beyond conventional logic).
Our inner illogicality is both our curse and our main gift. All that remains is to come to terms with this complexity, gradually discovering our uniqueness.
References and recommended reading:
- Bion, W. R. Experiences in Groups and Other Works. — M.: Kogito-Center, 2008. (Section on basic assumptions and group dynamics).
- Winnicott, D. W. Playing and Reality. — M.: Institute of General Humanitarian Studies, 2002. (Ideas on "good enough mother" and transitional space).
- Klein, M. Envy and Gratitude. A Study of Unconscious Sources. — St. Petersburg: B.S.K., 1997.
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
