Happiness and 'At Someone Else's Expense'
Article narration
Loading…We live in an era of total \"want.\" We want things, experiences, knowledge, and, of course, each other. But have you ever wondered what happens at the very moment a desire is finally satisfied? When the \"other\" becomes so understood and close that they turn into a part of ourselves?
And why, having reached the peak of intimacy, do we suddenly fall silent, and a diploma from a prestigious university leaves us feeling cheated, as if we were not given the most important thing? Let's try to understand this by tracing the surprising path from eager acquisition—to silence, and from learning—to the lost secret of mastery.
Stage One: \"You Are Mine,\" or Our Shared Field of Being
At the beginning of any healthy relationship—be it a romantic connection, a strong friendship, or a business partnership—lies the desire for appropriation. This sounds a bit possessive, but at its core, it's a natural process of assimilating what \"resonates\" with us. We like a person, their thoughts, their warmth, their way of looking at the world. We want this richness to become a part of our lives.
This period of eager assimilation is like a dance: we adapt to each other, absorb each other's habits, and learn to anticipate desires. And at a certain stage, magic happens: instead of two separate individuals, a single field of being emerges, a shared space of \"We\".
It would seem, here it is, happiness. We understood each other without needing to speak much. We are one. But this is precisely where the first paradox lies.
Silence on Air: Why Do We Stop Talking to Those We Love?
How often do we talk to ourselves? Surprisingly rarely. Usually, internal dialogue only activates during moments of acute conflict or agonizing choice. In a calm state, thoughts flow silently.
Approximately the same thing happens in a couple that has achieved ideal mutual understanding. When the other person becomes not just close, but literally an extension of you, the need for verbal contact paradoxically decreases. Why speak if I already know what they're thinking? But human nature is such that complete silence is detrimental to us. Conversations fade not because people have become strangers, but because they have grown bored with each other in the closed space of \"We.\"
\"Happiness without development turns into a swamp. For sparks to continue flying between two people, they need an outward focus—a common goal, idea, or problem that they will explore together.\"
The presence of an external "being" (be it building a dacha, raising children, or writing a book) brings back to the couple the need to communicate, negotiate, and get to know each other again in a new context.
Mastering the world: a natural instinct or a matter of manners?
The process of mastering "some other being" is embedded in us by nature. It is the engine of development. We see something new, and it seems wonderful, fascinating, alluring. We begin to want.
To want is a whole complex of actions: fantasizing, dreaming, thinking, planning, seeking resources, and finally, doing. It is precisely this – the ability to want and to do – that modern young people, who choose the life of hikikomori (voluntary recluses), lack so much. They get stuck at the fantasy stage because the real world requires entering into relationships, and relationships are always a risk and a tension.
But when we decide to break out of voluntary confinement and master something truly complex (a craft, a profession, an art), we find that the path to what we desire is paved not only with our enthusiasm.
The syndrome of the paid course: where does the master hide?
On the path to any mastery, there are two components:
- Skill (techne) — this is technology, a craft that can be described in textbooks.
- Attitude — this is the very secret that the Master transmits.
In the past, the structure of learning was strictly vertical. There was a Teacher who knew something, and a Student who was ready to walk the path to receive that something. The student did not assess their readiness for the next step; the Master, seeing the situation as a whole, did. In this vertical tension, respect was born, "long-term" goals for years ahead were formed, and, most importantly, the secret was preserved.
Today, the situation has changed dramatically. A modern student or course participant often believes: «I paid — I received». Money acts as an objectifier of reality, supposedly equalizing the parties. Universities, replicating a democratic communication model, blur the line between teacher and student, making them «pals».
It would seem, here it is — freedom! But this freedom comes at too high a price. By sharply reducing the distance, receiving all markers of horizontal acceptance, the student inadvertently loses the most important thing — the perspective of Mystery. He receives information (simulacra of knowledge) but does not receive initiation. He feels that something important is passing him by, but, not understanding the nature of this «important» thing, he begins to try to control the process.
Hence these endless demands for verbatim instructions: «Write me a precise list of questions for the session», «Create a step-by-step guide». Standardization of competencies kills the spirit. The ability to perform specific operations does not replace the embodiment in the position of a Master.
«A Master — is not someone who knows all the answers from a textbook. It is someone who is capable of taking full responsibility in a situation of absolute uncertainty».
By the way, about crusts...
Do you remember the famous scene in the tavern «Three Gudgeons» from the film «The Adventures of Buratino» (1975)? Hungry Buratino, who doesn't yet know how to «play by the rules», honestly asks: «Three crusts of bread». But Fox Alice and Cat Basilio, who have already mastered the art of simulation, immediately start to be capricious: «Give me a duck!.. Oh, what a nasty duck, give me another!» — «Crucian carp! Two crucian carp, no — three, or better yet, five!».
And all this, mind you, at someone else's expense. So it is in modern education: the student pays with their «coins» (time, money, effort), and they are promised a Field of Miracles, where a tree of competencies will grow from three crusts.
Conclusion. Reclaim your vertical
- Endure the tension. Seek the vertical. Allow yourself to truly desire.
- Seek a Master, not just a "credential". Choose those from whom there is truly something to learn, and be prepared for the journey to be longer than advertisements promise.
- Trust the process. Accept that your readiness for the next step will not be judged by you.
- Step out of the cozy "We" cocoon. In personal relationships, seek common external goals so that your conversations do not fall silent but move to a new level.
And remember: the mystery exists. It is not given by price list. And this is what makes life — and mastery, and love — a truly profound adventure.
📚 List of Used and Recommended Literature:
Philosophy of Consumption and Simulation:
1. Jean Baudrillard. "Simulacra and Simulation" (1981). A fundamental work explaining how in modern society signs and symbols (in our context — diplomas and "credentials") replace reality itself (real knowledge and mastery).
2. Erich Fromm. "To Have or to Be?" (1976). A classic work on the difference between the desire to appropriate the world ("You are mine") and the ability to truly live life in development and creation.
Psychology of Relationships and Loneliness:
3. Viktor Frankl. "Man's Search for Meaning" (1946). A book that helps understand why an enclosed "We" inevitably leads to an existential vacuum (boredom) and why a person always needs an external, transcendent meaning for happiness.
4. Tamaki Saito. "Hikikomori: Adolescence Without End" (2013). A deep study of the phenomenon of voluntary isolation, where the fear of truly engaging with the world makes a person get stuck in a stage of endless fantasies.
The Nature of Mastery and Initiation:
5. Mircea Eliade. "Secret Societies: Rites of Initiation and Consecration" (1956). Reveals the archetype of Master and Apprentice. Shows why true knowledge is impossible without "vertical" tension, respect, and passing through symbolic difficulties.
6. Rollo May. "Love and Will" (1969). A study of how modern man loses the ability to "truly desire" and why standardization and excessive control kill the living spirit in both profession and personal life.
7. Illustration: Pieter Bruegel the Elder — "The Land of Cockaigne" (1567). Context: A visual satire on a world of total consumption, where "ducks and carp" fall directly into one's mouth, and the verticality of mastery is ultimately overcome by the horizontality of complacent laziness. An ideal portrait of those who expect happiness "à la carte."
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
