Freedom as a Source within the Field of Irreversibilities

Психология
Дмитрий
Дмитрий Тимофеев
27 сентября 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Freedom as a Source within the Field of Irreversibilities

The Subject's Position in Late Modernity

Late modernity can be characterized as an era of total formal attribution of subjectivity. The individual is endowed with an unprecedented volume of rights, legal opportunities, and tools for self-expression. They are encouraged to be the «architect of their own life» and the «entrepreneur of themselves.» The system demands constant engagement, flexibility, creativity, and efficiency from them.

However, at the same time, a real erosion of subjectivity occurs. The ontological foundations for exercising this formally granted freedom are systematically undermined: time is capitalized and fragmented, psychological resources are depleted by information overload. The act itself becomes extremely complicated. To receive a basic service, one must go through 14 steps on a website; to protect data — recall one of 47 passwords. These are not simply «inconveniences,» but a form of dispersed power that does not prohibit, but complicates, requiring the subject to be the manager of their own life instead of its author. The result: the subject cannot act, although formally they can. Their refusal is not a choice, but a resource collapse.

The Cartesian Operation: Introducing the Irremediable Gap

To understand the nature of the modern subject, one must return to the moment of its foundation. Descartes' operation «Cogito ergo sum» is usually interpreted as an affirmation of the autonomy of reason. However, its main consequence lies deeper. Descartes grasped a fundamental need that arose at the moment of the collapse of old regulators (tradition, community). He gave the subject a point of support and the ability to organize their intentionality in a world where meanings are no longer given from above.

The operation «I think, therefore I am» is an act that allows one to take a position from which it is possible to manage one's certainty. However, this act created an irremediable gap between certainty («I am certain that I think») and veracity («I know for certain that this is my thought, and not one imposed from outside»). This gap generates basic existential anxiety — the price for the possibility of being a source. Anxiety here is irremediable — it is a condition for the possibility of subjectivity as such. The task of modern subjectivity is not to eliminate this gap, but to learn to act within it.

The Traumatic Experience of Refusal and the Implosive Revolution of Unwillingness

What appears from the outside as irresponsible refusal or procrastination is experienced from within by the subject as defeat. They do not choose «not to do» — they cannot do, because the cost of action exceeds their available resources. The subject is stuck at the threshold. This state is total:

  • Cognitive: the subject knows what needs to be done, but the cognitive limit is exhausted.
  • Energetic: «I can't bring myself to do it» — this is not a metaphor, but an accurate description of nervous system exhaustion.
  • Existential: Identity is fragmented. There is a formal "I" that knows it needs to act, and a real "I" that is paralyzed. Between them is an abyss filled with shame and self-blame.

"The implosive revolution of unwillingness" is a state of being stuck. The system and the subject themselves tend to interpret this as a breakdown, a symptom of pathology that needs urgent correction. However, in the logic of existential analysis, this is a stage. Without this stage, it is impossible to abandon old, instrumental forms of subjectivity and encounter the void, in which alone something authentic can be born.

Field of Irrevocabilities

The subject is always already in a field where procedures operate that cannot be canceled or bypassed:

  • Descartes' Rupture: the gap between certainty and authenticity.
  • Foucault's Power: power is diffused everywhere, any action is embedded in its structure.
  • Lacan's Lack: the fundamental deficit is unfillable, absolute completeness is unattainable.
  • Derrida's Différance: meaning always eludes, communication is never perfectly transparent.

The new architecture of the subject proposes not to fight against these givens, but to change one's attitude towards them. Subjectivation is a procedure that produces the subject as an effect of structure, but makes this effect irreversible and capable of redefining the structure itself. We accept lack, power, and elusive meaning as conditions of action, rather than obstacles to it.

From Instrumental Initiative to Ontological: "Doing NOTHING"

Freedom in this new architecture is not the absence of obstacles. Freedom is the ability to act in their presence. It is not the illusion of "I can do anything," but the position of "I act, knowing that not everything depends on me, but I choose the direction."

In the conditions of late modernity, instrumental initiative (reaction to stimuli, search for social approval, submission to the logic of efficiency) is completely privatized by the system. Authentic, ontological initiative begins with a radical step — with the right to stop.

Here arises a key clinical distinction:

  • «Not doing anything» — is passivity, avoidance, a vacuum that is immediately filled with informational noise (doomscrolling, surrogate consumption).
  • «DOING NOTHING» — is an active, conscious practice of holding oneself at the point of ontological uncertainty. It is a refusal to fill the void, to allow an inner source to be born.

The Observing Self: a clinical alternative to the «Doing» mode

In phenomenological psychology and third-wave cognitive therapy (ACT, MBCT), this transition is described as a shift in mental modes. The Cartesian subject — is a function of constant action, doubt, and problem-solving (doing mode). When this mode is active around the clock, the psyche burns out.

The alternative — is a position of pure presence, the «being mode» or The Observing Self. This is the instance within a person that is not involved in the race, does not evaluate, does not suffer from unachieved goals, and does not need proof of its significance. It simply witnesses what is happening. The trauma of modern man is that he is stuck: he can no longer «do» (exhausted), but has not yet learned to «just be» (observe). The practice of «DOING NOTHING» — is a bridge to the Observer's position, where subjectivity is restored through conscious presence, not through frantic achievement.

The Tribe as a Therapeutic Community

A positive way out of this crisis is impossible in absolute isolation. It requires the formation of new «tribes» — therapeutic and supportive communities. These are not escapist communes, but modern practice spaces (group therapy, support groups) whose functions are as follows:

  1. Protective space: a zone free from demands for efficiency, where stopping is legitimized.
  2. De-stigmatization: sharing experiences of going through an existential crisis, removing personal shame for «unwillingness».
  3. Shared practice: joint acquisition of mindfulness skills and return to corporeality.

It is in such a space that the atrophied "muscle of subjectivity" gets a chance for recovery. One learns to act not from a reaction to an external stimulus, but from an internal source, while maintaining the position of an Observer.

Conclusion

We stand on the threshold of a fundamental anthropological shift. The "Revolution of Unwillingness" — is a diagnosis, but not a sentence. Further movement is possible only by transitioning from a passive "I cannot" to an active "I can do NOTHING". This requires the courage to face one's own emptiness. The final synthesis is a new form of subjectivity: the ability to act as a source within a field of inevitabilities, while maintaining an internal position as a witness who does not doubt their right to exist.

From the editors.
The choice of Mark Rothko's abstract color fields as a visual anchor for this article is deeply symbolic. His minimalist works (such as the uncompromising "Black on Grey") are completely devoid of objects, plots, and familiar narratives — they demand a radical pause from the viewer. This is a pure aesthetic visualization of the therapeutic transition from the exhausting mode of "doing" to the liberating mode of "being". Rothko does not entertain the viewer or present them with cognitive tasks to decipher meanings; he invites them to endure absolute presence and confront their own existential emptiness without anxiety. It is at this point of total pause, where the modern subject learns to "do NOTHING" and transitions into the position of a pure Observer, that the restoration of authentic, non-system-imposed initiative becomes possible.

Recommended literature:

  1. Boltanski, L., Chiapello, E. (2011). The New Spirit of Capitalism. — Moscow: New Literary Review.
  2. Descartes, R. (1994). Meditations on First Philosophy. — Moscow: Thought.
  3. Foucault, M. (2007). The Hermeneutics of the Subject. — St. Petersburg: Science.
  4. Han, B.-C. (2020). The Burnout Society. — Moscow: Ad Marginem.
  5. Fisher, M. (2020). Capitalist Realism. — Moscow: Ad Marginem.
  6. Hayes, S. C., Strosahl, K. D., Wilson, K. G. (2020). Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: The Process and Practice of Mindful Change. — M.: Dialectika.
  7. Williams, M., Penman, D. (2018). Mindfulness: A Practical Guide to Finding Peace in a Frantic World (MBCT). — M.: Mann, Ivanov i Ferber.
  8. May, R. (2001). The Discovery of Being. — M.: Institute of General Humanitarian Studies.
Онлайн-психотерапияproEgoИдентичностьДмитрий ТимофеевПризнаниеПсихотерапияПсихологпсихология
Views: 165

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!