Epidemic of Infantilism: Psychoanalysis of Low Labor Productivity in Russia and How Businesses Can Build a System of Adult Responsibility

Бизнес
Дана
Дана Янсон
7 марта 2026

Article narration

Loading…
Epidemic of Infantilism: Psychoanalysis of Low Labor Productivity in Russia and How Businesses Can Build a System of Adult Responsibility

The Russian economy is at a bifurcation point. The time when the internal inefficiency of business processes could be generously compensated by cheap hydrocarbons has come to an end. Today, the survival and competitiveness of companies depend exclusively on one factor — labor efficiency, both intellectual and physical.

Owners and CEOs recognize the need for transformation but regularly face a deafening wall of total staff indifference. To understand what to do, businesses need to go beyond classic HR management and look at the problem through the lens of psychoanalysis and systemic organizational management.


The Productivity Gap: Figures and Reality

Statistics: labor productivity in Russia is 3–4 times lower than in countries we call strategic partners. The gap in output per employee is enormous: if in the USA this figure is around $150,000 per person, then here it is only $32,000.

Analysts often attribute this to outdated equipment and technological backwardness, the roots of which go back to the 90s. Undoubtedly, the lack of new capital assets plays a role. However, as a psychoanalyst working with the corporate sector, I assert: buying new machinery or implementing advanced IT systems does not solve the problem. The main impediment to the Russian economy — is a deep psychological crisis of subjectivity and widespread infantilism in the workplace.

Historical Psychoanalysis: Where Did the "Paycheck" Mentality Come From?

How did it happen that a people capable of completing a five-year plan in three years and withstanding an existential threat during the Great Patriotic War came to total irresponsibility?

During the years of industrialization and war, the most powerful, albeit harsh, ideological Super-Ego (Superego) served as the driver of hyper-productivity. People worked not so much for material wealth as for a transcendent idea. They were united by a common meaning of survival and creation.

But what happened next? The generation that went through wars and hardships unconsciously tried to protect their children from any discomfort. This overprotection sowed the first seeds of widespread infantilism. During the era of stagnation, a fatal linguistic and mental substitution occurred: people stopped "earning" and started "receiving a paycheck". The prestige of a "cushy job" emerged, where the ultimate skill was pretending to work and getting stable money for it.

Then came the 1990s. The ideological Super-Ego collapsed overnight. An infantilized generation, unaccustomed to subjectivity, faced wild capitalism. The psyche reacted with a defense mechanism — dissociation and learned helplessness. A destructive social contract was firmly established: «We pretend to work, and you pretend to pay us».

Clinical Picture: A Symptom on the Assembly Line

During supervisions of top managers and owners of large businesses, I hear the same existential cry: «I don't understand how to make them take responsibility for their work!» The infantilism of employees leads to errors, delays, and unfulfilled plans, which directly translates into financial losses for the company. Employees are only interested in the payday. Missed deadlines, broken expensive equipment, defects — none of this causes them internal discomfort.

Let's consider a typical case from recent practice. On the car assembly line, an employee forgets to install an important part. Three quality control specialists (QC) successively miss this defect. As a result, the car reaches the client and causes a serious accident.

Who bears existential, reputational, and legal responsibility? The CEO/owner. The person who invested millions in the control system, prescribed regulations, and provided working conditions. And what happens to employees who committed fatal negligence? At most — loss of bonus and a reprimand.

From a psychoanalytic perspective, this is a clear «Parent-Child» dynamic. The CEO acts as an omnipotent, hyper-responsible Parent who ultimately pays for all the broken windows. The employee is in the position of an irresponsible Child. Loss of bonus for them is akin to being «put in the corner and wagged a finger at». This does not foster adult responsibility; it only generates childlike resentment towards the «mean boss».

International Context: The Adult Paradigm

How is this problem solved in countries with high labor efficiency?

  • Asian model (Japan). The Toyota Production System (TPS) is based on collective adult responsibility. Any line worker has the right and obligation to pull the «Andon» cord and stop the entire conveyor if they see a defect. This is a «Grown-up—Grown-up» trust system, reinforced by the strictest social ostracism for indifference to the overall result.
  • Western model (Europe, USA). It is built on radical individualization and strict contractual boundaries. Professional negligence there results not in a reprimand, but in career collapse, loss of license, and multi-million dollar personal lawsuits. Responsibility there is internalized (built into the psyche as an Ego function).

Systemic solutions: how to treat institutional infantilism

Attempting to cure irresponsibility with micromanagement, fines, or, conversely, corporate parties — is pointless. Unprofessional behavior caused by infantilism requires a deep restructuring of the corporate environment.

For a company's economy to become competitive, businesses need to implement the following systemic changes:

1. Dismantling the "Parent — Child" dynamic

Most Russian companies pride themselves on being "one big family." From the perspective of organizational psychoanalysis, this is the most destructive metaphor for business. In a family, children are loved unconditionally, fed regardless of their usefulness, and broken cups are silently cleaned up by parents. By calling the company a "family," the owner unconsciously grants personnel legitimate permission for infantilism.

Owners and top managers must exit the classic dramatic "Karpman Drama Triangle," where they endlessly cycle between the roles of Rescuer (who works at night, correcting others' mistakes) and Persecutor (who yells at meetings and cuts bonuses).

Dismantling the "Parent — Child" system means abandoning the "educator" function. A boss should not punish. A fine or reprimand from a manager is perceived by an infantile employee not as responsibility, but as "a belt from an angry dad." This only provokes childish rebellion and a desire to deceive the system. The adult model (Adult — Adult) is built on strict partnership boundaries and natural consequences. The solution is to deprive the employee of the opportunity to act out their sabotage personally against the manager. Their work should be evaluated, and monetary penalties imposed, not by the boss, but by the system and the work environment itself. And this brings us to the main mechanism of transformation.

2. Decentralization of subjectivity: from vertical supervision to horizontal collective responsibility

In classical management, it's customary to speak of «delegating responsibility.» From a psychoanalytic perspective, this is an illusion and a linguistic trap. Responsibility cannot be delegated (issued from above like an order); it can only be taken voluntarily — it's an internal function of a mature Ego. As long as the CEO tries to «impose» responsibility on an infantile employee, the latter will play the national game — sabotage the process, feign intense activity, and look for ways to outwit the «Father-leader.»

This can only be changed by a radical shift in the focus of control: from vertical (boss — subordinate) to horizontal (colleague — colleague).

How does this work in practice? It is necessary to break down large, impersonal departments into autonomous mini-teams (cells) that bear collective responsibility for the final, measurable product. But the main condition — their financial income, bonuses, and comfort must be strictly linked to the results of the entire cell.

Returning to the example of car assembly: if a mechanic forgot to install a part, and the quality control inspector didn't notice it, financial sanctions should be borne by both, as well as their entire shift.

The psychological mechanism of this solution. In the Russian mentality, avoiding management demands historically does not cause strong internal discomfort — it is perceived as normal protection from the «system.» However, letting down «your own» — colleagues with whom you work side-by-side every day — activates a completely different, ancient, and powerful mechanism of social shame and fear of ostracism (expulsion from the pack).

Intra-group pressure from a mature team works dozens of times more strictly and effectively than any director's orders. When an infantile employee, due to their negligence, deprives not only themselves but also their cell colleagues of bonuses, the manager no longer needs to chase them with a stick. The team itself will either force them to mature and start working diligently, or systematically «push» them out of its composition, as they are literally reaching into their colleagues' pockets. The transition to decentralized autonomous teams removes the role of supervisor from top management's shoulders and initiates the process of business self-regulation.

3. Integration of Professional Psychotherapy (EAP) as a Tool for Maturation and Separation

Most Russian companies make a fatal mistake: they confuse psychological business support (EAP) with the entertainment and relaxation industry (well-being). By paying for employee subscriptions to meditations, lectures on "positive thinking," or conversations with life coaches from the HR budget, businesses only fall deeper into the "Parent-Child" trap. Employees perceive this as another corporate "pacifier" designed to make their stay at a disliked job more pleasant. This does not cure irresponsibility; it only makes infantilism more comfortable.

True corporate psychotherapy is not a massage chair. It's an operating room. It's a rigorous process of confronting an individual with reality, aimed at dismantling learned helplessness and the victim syndrome.

How exactly does this work in the session? 
When an infantile employee comes to a psychologist complaining about a "bad company" or a "cruel boss," they unconsciously expect the therapist to become that unconditionally loving Rescuer-Parent. But a professional analyst does not play along.
As my colleague, proEgo psychoanalyst Denis Kulichkov in his article «I Want to Hear You: Analytical Listening», thoroughly explains, the specialist is able to grasp this hidden infantile modality. The analyst hears not only the employee's historical complaint but also their interpsychic plea: ".Take responsibility for my pain.". By not engaging in this game, the therapist frustrates the client's infantile part and carefully returns their subjectivity to them.

This is precisely the task of a professional EAP provider — to facilitate the employee's separation from childish expectations and to make them realize that their work is their personal capital, not a burden.

How does this work at the product architecture level? On the proEgo platform, we have embedded this maturation mechanism into the very economic model of the service through the implementation of a therapeutic franchise (co-financing).

The most destructive practice in the market, for example, corporate  VMI — is 100% free psychologist consultations. When a company fully pays for a session, the phenomenon of «psychological tourism» arises. The employee comes with the mindset of a Child: «HR gave me a free psychologist, well, come on, make me feel good, motivate me». A therapeutic alliance is impossible under such conditions. The budget burns to no purpose.

The adult (clinical) paradigm requires participation. When the employer covers 75–80% of the session cost, and the remaining 20–25% is paid by the employee out of their own pocket, an immediate transformation occurs. This small financial contribution activates the «reality principle» in the psyche. The person stops being a passive consumer of a corporate benefit and becomes an investor in their own mental health and effectiveness. This co-payment filters out «tourists» and retains those who are truly ready to work with their resistance, aggression, and burnout.

Summary
Attempts to boost labor productivity with slogans or fines do not work. Intellectual and high-tech labor requires a mature psyche. Only by transitioning corporate culture from a «strict regime kindergarten» to a space of contracts between Adults can businesses make the necessary shift to high productivity and accountability for results.
Investments in clinical mental health infrastructure (EAP) are a direct tool for protecting the payroll fund and converting irresponsible «salary recipients» into adult partners who generate company profits and create a competitive product.

Author: Dana Yanson, PhD in Psychology, psychoanalyst,
founder of proEgo B2B professional psychotherapy platform


List of Recommended Literature and Sources

Economics, Sociology, and the Problem of Labor Productivity:

  1. Voskoboynikov I. B., Gimpelson V. E. et al. (2021). Labor Productivity and Russian Human Capital: Paradoxes of Interconnection. HSE University Report.
  2. Leontiev D. A. (2011). Personal Potential: Structure and Diagnostics. M.: Smysl.
  3. Radaev V. V. (2019). Millennials: How Russian Society is Changing. M.: HSE Publishing House.

Psychoanalysis and Organizational Psychology: 

     4.   Kets de Vries, Manfred (2008). The Neurotic Organization:
           Diagnosis and Treatment
. M.: Olimp-Biznes.
     5.   Berne, Eric (2014). Games People Play. M.: Eksmo.
     6.   Karpman, Stephen (2014). A Game Free Life.

Management, Accountability, and Management Systems: 

     7.   Liker, Jeffrey (2005). The Toyota Way: 14 Management Principles from the World's Greatest Manufacturer. M.: Alpina Business Books.
     8.   Taleb, Nassim Nicholas (2018). Skin in the Game:
           Hidden Asymmetries in Daily Life
. M.: KoLibri.
    
9.   American Psychological Association (APA) (2022). Work and
           Well-Being Survey
.

Illustration for the article:

Painting by Pieter Bruegel the Elder — "Children's Games" (1560)

The painting depicts a city filled with people seriously engaged in children's games. In the context of the article, this is a satire on modern companies where employees, instead of creating a real product, are busy shuffling papers, engaging in intrigues, imitating vigorous activity, and evading responsibility.

Views: 556

Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)

Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии

Пока нет комментариев. Будьте первым!