Grief and Melancholy: A Psychoanalytic Perspective and Reflection in Cinema
Article narration
Loading…The Many Faces of Loss
Currently, there is no single definition of loss, as each person defines this event in their own way, investing their unique meaning into it. Some will attribute a purely material character to loss, for example, losing keys, money, or other important things, while others will say that loss is necessarily death. And so, loss turns out to be an amazingly multifaceted phenomenon.
Each of us loses something in life, but the most acute grief arises when a loved one, dear to the heart, leaves life. At the same time, most people who have experienced the death of a loved one agree that such a loss is characterized by irreversibility and significance. The psyche suddenly encounters a fact that cannot be canceled, replayed, or corrected, and this demands a colossal internal restructuring from it.
Acute Grief Syndrome (Erich Lindemann)
One of the founders of the study of this complex topic is considered to be the German-American psychiatrist Erich Lindemann, who, in his research, observed relatives of patients who died in the clinic, as well as families of military personnel and victims of natural disasters.
He developed the concept of acute grief as a specific syndrome with psychological and somatic symptoms, which can:
- arise immediately after the crisis;
- be delayed;
- not manifest explicitly;
- appear in an excessively emphasized form.
Among the main symptoms, Lindemann identified physical suffering, preoccupation with the image of the deceased, guilt, hostile reactions, and loss of former patterns of behavior. A person literally forgets what it is like to simply live their ordinary life; their body and thoughts are completely paralyzed by the loss.
Mourning and Melancholia (Sigmund Freud)
Sigmund Freud made an equally significant contribution to the development of the topic in his work "Mourning and Melancholia." The research was significantly influenced by the historical context of World War I, as well as personal experience, as two of Freud's sons were at the front, and later his daughter Sophie and young grandson died. It is not surprising that this work is called the load-bearing column of the psychoanalytic theory of depression.
Freud explores the question of human reactions in connection with a real loss, with disappointment in a loved one, or with the loss of an ideal. Why do some people react with an affect of sadness, which they overcome over time, while others sink into a severe depressive state — melancholia? The symptoms of these states look very similar: depressed mood, loss of interest in the outside world, loss of ability to love, slowed thinking and speech, slowed movements.
The main difference is as follows:
- Grief is a normal reaction to loss, where a person gradually recognizes the loss and its significance, allowing them to eventually integrate this experience into their life and return to normal functioning. The normal process of grieving goes through difficult but necessary stages: from recognizing reality and temporary overinvestment of memory to gradually withdrawing energy from the lost object and returning it to one's self for new relationships.
- Melancholy, in turn, is a pathological state. Freud wrote that in grief, the world became impoverished and empty, while in melancholy, it was the ego itself. In melancholy, a person's self-aversion comes to the fore, and their cruel self-reproaches actually refer to the lost object. Psychoanalysis discovered that a melancholic's "I am worthless" actually means "You are worthless," and the indignation from an injustice inflicted, through a special internal process, turns into depression. The shadow of the object falls on the ego, forcing the person to attack themselves instead of the one who left or brought disappointment.
Introjection and incorporation: the concept of the "crypt" (N. Abraham, M. Torok, J.-C. Racamier)
French analysts Nicolas Abraham and Maria Torok supplemented this understanding by describing a crucial difference between two ways of coping with loss – between introjection and incorporation:
1. Introjection is a healthy path, a gradual expansion of the self, where we acknowledge reality, experience the pain, and carefully integrate the memory of the deceased person into our personality. We remain ourselves but are enriched by this experience.
2. Incorporation is a melancholic dead end, a fantasized swallowing of the object whole. When a person cannot bear the real disappearance of a loved one, their psyche performs a magical act: it places this object inside itself to hide it from reality and pretend that no loss has occurred.
To describe such a state, they introduced the concept of the crypt (or tomb) within the ego. An isolated, cemented space, a crypt, is created in the psyche, where the departed object is buried alive. It continues to live there its secret life, neither processed nor mourned. The person carries this tomb within themselves for years, expending an enormous amount of energy to maintain the illusion that everything has remained as before.
Jean-Claude Racamier expanded this picture, describing how the maternal object can literally occupy a child's psyche, leaving no room for their own identity. In a situation of unprocessed grief, this internal takeover becomes absolute. The child's psyche is flooded with the ghosts of parental unspoken material, its secrets, its guilt, and its own depression, turning them into a permanent guardian of someone else's crypt.
The metaphor of the crypt in cinema: the film "The Eternal Daughter"
There are many films about loss in cinema, but it so happened that I recently watched Joanna Hogg's film "The Eternal Daughter." While watching, I realized that this film remarkably accurately illustrates the concept of the crypt, as written about by Abraham and Torok, and the very maternal engulfment explored by Racamier.
The main character, Julie (a film director), brings her elderly mother, Rosalind, to an old mansion converted into a hotel. Rosalind once lived here as a child, and the place is filled with her memories, not always happy ones. Julie tries to write a script, make a film about her mother, and hopes that through these holidays and conversations, she can grow closer to her, unravel her essence. From the very first shots, we are immersed in an atmosphere that literally breathes melancholy. The hotel is surrounded by a thick, impenetrable fog. Inside, we see endless empty corridors, dim green light, creaking floorboards, the whistling wind in the windows, and the constant, oppressive noise of a huge, empty house. There are no other guests in this mansion, only a strange, cold girl at the reception and an elderly caretaker, Bill.
Narcissistic fusion and psychic intrusion
During the viewing, one quickly notices an important detail: this hotel in the middle of nowhere is not perceived as a real geographical location. It looks like that very crypt, a tomb within Julie's psyche. It is an isolated space, cut off from the outside world by a fog of repression, where Julie tries to keep her mother.
The director makes a brilliant move: both Julie and her mother Rosalind are played by the same actress — Tilda Swinton. We see their faces on screen, sitting opposite each other at a table, having dinner, talking, but they are the faces of one person. Before us unfolds a metaphor of narcissistic fusion and incorporation, where the Self has completely identified with the lost object. The mother's shadow did not just fall on the daughter; it erased her own contours. Julie literally sealed herself in this space with her primary object.
Julie and her mother's relationship is woven from fragile, almost painful tenderness and hidden tension:
- Julie exhibits suffocating care, constantly checking if there's a draft from the window, if the food is warm enough, if her mother slept well.
- She records conversations with her mother on a voice recorder, trying to capture every phrase. This is the over-investment in the object Freud wrote about.
- Julie desperately tries to hold onto her elusive mother through control and fixation on details.
But behind this ideal care lies a deep sense of guilt and an inability to separate. Rosalind, walking through the hotel or sitting in an armchair, constantly returns to painful memories of the past, to the miscarriage she had within these walls, to the death of her brother. And Julie unconsciously swallows this maternal depression. She cries when her mother is sad; she cannot sleep if her mother is worried. Racamier would call this a total psychic invasion, where the daughter has no right to her own feelings, separate from her mother's.
Julie tries to write a script, but the work doesn't progress, and it's understandable, as creativity is impossible in a crypt. To make a film, one needs their own observer's position, their separate Self. Julie, however, is entirely occupied with sustaining the life support of her mother's ghost within her tomb. She is not living her own life; she is serving someone else's memory.
The Destruction of Illusion and the Open Ending
The film's climax occurs on Rosalind's birthday. Julie organizes a dinner, brings a birthday cake, but the perfect facade of fusion collapses. The mother refuses to eat, old resentments surface, and Julie is torn by tears and helplessness. And at this moment, the illusion of the crypt bursts.
We suddenly understand what could have been guessed from the very beginning. Julie's mother has long been dead. This entire trip to the foggy hotel, all these dinners and long conversations before bed — it was a mental re-enactment, played out in Julie's psyche. She came to this mansion alone. She sits alone at an empty table in the restaurant, and the caretaker Bill brings dinner only for her.
Julie could not cope with her mother's death; she could not bear the normal work of grief and instead built a crypt within herself, incorporating Rosalind. She became her mother; she spoke for her, felt for her, and lived her memories. The film shows us what a depressive dead end looks like from within, like a solitary dialogue with a ghost in the empty, echoing corridor of one's own Self. This confrontation with the ringing emptiness becomes a moment of terrifying truth for her.
When Julie finally admits that her mother is not physically at the table, the crypt begins to crack. She cries real tears, and these are no longer tears of guilt or codependency, but the first tears of real, cleansing grief. In the final shots, the fog around the hotel dissipates slightly, Julie sits down at the table, and her script finally begins to be written. It seems that the liberated energy, which for years was spent on maintaining the tomb, returns to her.
But here the director leaves the ending open, forcing the viewer to ponder what exactly happened within these foggy walls. Did Julie truly manage to destroy the inner crypt, separate from her mother, and initiate the real work of grief? Or is this momentary release, the written script, and leaving the hotel — merely another turn in the melancholic script that she is doomed to reproduce in her psyche again and again, returning to the suffocating, yet so safe fusion with the ghost? Each viewer decides this for themselves, because the line between a real exit from the crypt and eternal, submissive confinement within it always remains too thin.
Article's Visual Image: Arnold Böcklin — "Isle of the Dead" (1880–1886)
From the E-J Editorial Board
We chose this particular painting:
To visually accompany this profound exploration of the psychology of loss, the editorial board selected one of the most enigmatic and melancholic canvases in the history of world painting — "Isle of the Dead" by the Swiss symbolist Arnold Böcklin. This painting serves as a flawless metaphor for the article's key concepts:
1. Crystallization of the "crypt" concept: The solitary island, carved into rocks with cemented tombs, surrounded by a dense wall of dark cypresses, literally materializes on canvas the psychoanalytic theory of Nicolas Abraham and Maria Torok. This is precisely the "crypt within the self" — an isolated, frozen space that the grieving person constructs in their psyche to hide the lost object from merciless reality.
2. Echo of the foggy hotel and melancholy: The atmosphere of the painting remarkably resonates with the cinematic space of the film "The Eternal Daughter." The mirror-like, absolutely still water surface, the silence enveloping the island, and the heavy premonition of mystery reproduce that very fog of repression and the endless empty corridors of the mansion where Julie immured herself with her mother's ghost.
3. The figure of the crypt guardian: The white, faceless figure in the boat, silently accompanying the shroud-wrapped object towards the stone crypts, echoes Jean-Claude Racamier's description of a child who becomes "the permanent guardian of another's crypt." It symbolizes the melancholic Self, having completely abandoned its own forward movement and dedicated itself to serving eternal memory and narcissistic fusion with the deceased.Böcklin's "Isle of the Dead" is a visual dialogue with a ringing inner emptiness, which helps the reader not just intellectually understand, but also feel the depressive dead-end where the object's shadow has forever erased the contours of a living human personality.
List of mentioned sources:
1. Lindemann, Erich — studies of acute grief symptomatology and syndrome.
2. Freud, Sigmund — psychoanalytic work "Mourning and Melancholia" (1917).
3. Abraham, Nicolas and Torok, Maria — psychoanalytic works describing the concepts of introjection, incorporation, and the "crypt within the self."
4. Racamier, Jean-Claude — psychoanalytic studies of maternal engulfment and psychic intrusion (narcissistic fusion).
5. Hogg, Joanna (director) — feature film "The Eternal Daughter" (2022).
Комментарии аккредитованных экспертов (0)
Войдите, чтобы оставлять комментарии
