Editor's Note:
This material was prepared as part of the clinical section of the proEgo Expert Journal. The text describes complex psychological states related to loss.
about the visual metaphor
As the main illustration for this material, we chose the painting by Danish artist Vilhelm Hammershøi «Interior with Young Woman from the Back» (1903–1904).
This work is a strikingly accurate visualization of the state of «frozen grief» and the phenomenon of ambiguous loss. On the canvas, time seems to have stopped. A solitary female figure, frozen in a semi-empty, subdued space with her back to the viewer, physically conveys a sense of deep social isolation and emotional numbness. She doesn't express acute hysteria, she does nothing — she simply exists in a state of lingering, frozen anticipation. This image brilliantly reflects the essence of unbearable uncertainty when a person's life is put on hold and gets stuck in a dead-end gap between hope and despair, unable to move forward.
Author: Anastasia Azarnova,
psychiatrist, psychotherapist at proEgo platform
Loss — a natural, though extremely painful, part of the human experience. Sometimes we lose something insignificant: carelessly leave an umbrella on a metro seat or throw away a beloved but broken cup. Sometimes it's something more personal and significant — job loss, divorce, relocation, or the death of a loved one. Some losses we choose ourselves, others simply happen to us, disrupting our familiar way of life.
From a clinical perspective, the grieving process — is a natural evolutionary mechanism for the psyche to adapt to loss. No matter how difficult this process may be, normally it always begins with the same starting point: the recognition of the fact and irreversibility of the change that has occurred. The mind states: «This is no longer in my life». Relying on this cruel but objective fact, the psyche initiates the complex work of grief.
But what if this reference point is missing? What if instead, there's a vague, blurred spot? A person finds themselves in a state where the object of attachment is neither alive nor dead, neither here nor there — it lies beyond all clear concepts we are used to relying on.
Anatomy of Ambiguous Loss
In evidence-based psychology, the term «ambiguous loss», coined by researcher and psychotherapist Pauline Boss, is used to describe this phenomenon. This is a special, complicated type of grief that occurs when a person is physically absent but psychologically present (in thoughts, hopes, expectations). In the situation of a missing person, grief is easily «frozen» and stalled, not letting go of its bearer and literally paralyzing their life. The person is trapped: they can neither mourn their loved one, nor restore a relationship with them, nor move on with their life.
The Trap of Uncertainty and Cognitive Dissonance
The human brain is not evolutionarily adapted to long-term endurance of uncertainty. We need to «close our gestalts» — to build a complete picture of the world. In the situation of a missing person, the brain enters an endless cycle of prediction error. On the one hand, reality (an empty room, lack of communication) dictates the need to grieve. On the other hand, the absence of proof of death feeds hope.
Classic models of grief (for example, the well-known stages of Kübler-Ross) do not work here. A person gets stuck in a pendulum between hope and despair. Hope, which is a lifeline in other life circumstances, becomes a torture in ambiguous loss. If a person starts mourning the missing person, they feel acute guilt for «betrayal» («What if they are alive, and I\'m already burying them?»). If they cling to hope, they block adaptation to reality and put their life on hold, which can last for decades.
Social Vacuum and «Disenfranchised Grief»
Another extremely difficult aspect of such a loss is the absence of social support in the form of rituals and traditions. Funerals, memorial services, and condolence protocols exist not for the dead; they are created for the living. The ritual serves the function of social recognition of the loss and transitions an individual into the status of a mourner, granting them the right to community support.
When a person is not physically present, but there is also no grave, society is lost. Those around don't know how to react: expressing condolences seems tactless (as there is still hope), while encouraging seems cruel. This gives rise to the phenomenon of «disenfranchised grief», described by Kenneth Doka. Society does not fully acknowledge the family's right to grieve, leading to stigmatization, awkward silence, and deep social isolation.
Psychotherapy Strategy
Working with ambiguous loss is a long process that requires careful construction of new supports. Due to a technical layout error, we have restored the full structure of the therapeutic strategy:
-
Legitimization of grief. It is of paramount importance to recognize and legitimize the client's right to grieve "outside the rules" — for example, to give oneself time and a safe space for emotional denial of the loss.
-
Development of dialectical thinking. The basis of adaptation is the ability to hold two contradictory facts simultaneously. The use of the conjunction "and" instead of "or". In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), this is called uncertainty tolerance: "My loved one is missing, and perhaps they will never return, AND I must continue to care for my children and live my life".
-
Integration of uncertainty (Tonkin's Model). This is not a path to regaining control over a situation (which is impossible), but to restoring the individual's sovereignty over their own life. According to Lois Tonkin's model, the pain of loss does not diminish over time, but the person's life itself can grow larger, expanding around this grief. Therapy helps to find a place for the new uncertainty and integrate it so that it ceases to destroy the foundation of the personality.
Conclusion
Psychotherapy in cases of ambiguous loss is not about finding answers. The psychologist's office doesn't have the answer to "where is he?". It is a search for a way to endure questions and to take care of oneself. It is a meticulous, slow construction of an inner fortress that will withstand the pressure of the unknown, without self-violence or haste.
To admit that carrying such a burden alone is unbearably difficult, and to seek professional support — this is the first and most important step towards reclaiming your right to life.
References:
Boss, P. (2006). Loss, Trauma, and Resilience: Therapeutic Work With Ambiguous Loss. W. W. Norton & Company.
Doka, K. J. (2002). Disenfranchised Grief: New Directions, Challenges, and Strategies for Practice. Research Press.
Tonkin, L. (1996). Growing around grief: another way of looking at grief and recovery. Bereavement Care, 15(1), 10.
Worden, J. W. (2018). Grief Counseling and Grief Therapy: A Handbook for the Mental Health Practitioner (5th ed.). Springer Publishing Company.
American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR).